What am I?

The answer is...'it'.


It is superfluous to the sentence.

I like that answer, it seems to fit. I have no idea what superfluous means.
Do you ever talk normal? :wink:

Thanks for all your input, my answer is advice. Please give your opinion on how valid you think this answer is.

Re: What am I?


I liked the riddle and advice fit the the other parts but this part I had a problem with.

"He who has it gives it." It sounds like it will be done. Period. It will happen.
There is no choice.
However not everyone who has advice gives it. So it doesn't seem to fit.
If can was in the sentence it would fit.

It is possible "He who has it gives it" but, will he give it?

I still agree with Tryagain that he talks weird.

Really,
I feel the answer ^ ^ ^ ^ is what that weird person up there said.

"it"

thanks tryingtohelp, although i disagree, i think by definition advice means to give.

advice
noun
an opinion which someone offers you about what you should do or how you should act in a particular situation. Cambridge Advanced Learner's Dictionary Online

I think if an opinion is not given is remains an opinion.

"It" maybe an alternate answer, I cant think of a way to disprove it although it seems to make everything rather pointless.

You can just call me tth

I love it!!!

Your answer "advice", you are right even per Webster's New World Dictionary. My edition says "opinion given as to what to do"
so by definition it is given. That was a good riddle. You should do more.

Guys, the answer is coffin. 100% sure, since I heard it before. (Yes I did join just to say the answer)