About
last week's Austrian elections.
The results appear inconspicuous enough; the Social-democrats lost a sliver, the Greens won some; the conservatives lost ground considerably, the far right got a good result, at least when you count the two parties it has splintered into (the FPOe and the BZOe) together. The 15% they got, added up, is frighteningly high, but in itself not unusual: Le Pen habitually gets the same in France.
There is an underlying story though, concerning the question how to deal with the far right. Throughout the 80s and the 90s, mainstream parties throughout Europe established various degrees of a 'cordon sanitaire', blocking any co-operation or government office for the far right. Though morally easily defensible, that didnt work out well politically, as the case of Belgium shows: each election cycle the party was kept out of all government structures, it won extra votes of resentment, gradually climbing and climbing until it was the biggest party.
Austria was the first country to break the mold. The conservative OeVP established a coalition government with the far-right FPOe. It was at first harshly criticized, even punished for it by the EU, with some diplomatic sanctions imposed on it.
But the isolation of Austria quickly crumbled, and four years later, the OeVP's leader Schuessel appeared wholly vindicated. It seemed that inviting the far right into government to actually take some responsibility itself turned out a masterstroke: by the next elections, the FPOe collapsed, seeing its vote share drop from around 27% to just 10%. This 'success' was echoed in the Netherlands. In 2002, the mainstream rightwing parties invited the List Pim Fortuyn (LPF), which had spectacularly shot up the political scene in the elections right after Fortuyn's murder, getting 18% of the vote out of nowhere, into government. The price was chaos in the Cabinet, but when the government collapsed after the briefest term ever had by a Dutch government and new elections were held, the vote of the LPF collapsed, from 18% to just 5%.
As Anton Pelinka writes in
this useful introductory evaluation of the Austrian elections in openDemocracy, "There was a lot of talk that Schüssel successfully domesticated [FPOe leader] Haider."
But, he continues, "in 2006, FP?--plus-BZ?- has emerged as an even more a decisive factor in Austrian politics." They're not dead yet. Their total has gone right back up. Once again, they are in a position to keep both the left and the mainstream right from a majority of its own, necessitating either a grand coalition or, less likely, their own inclusion into government. A grand coalition that is not born out of a common platform or political vision of OeVP and the socialdemocratic SPOe, but purely to keep the third force out. A grand coalition that in turn will be sure to boost the far right back up even further in the next elections.
Those who thought they had found the solution, are now back to square one.