http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/03/16/AR2006031601799_pf.html
"Keep the Islands Pure
Friday, March 17, 2006; A18
PRESIDENT BUSH has never been a great friend of environmental protection. Yet his administration may be about to pull off, without much fanfare, a triumph of ecosystem conservation. Then again, it may not.
The Northwestern Hawaiian Islands, an unpopulated string of islands stretching more than 1,200 miles from Hawaii's populated islands, make up one of this country's most remote and pristine wildernesses. The waters around them form its largest coral reef ecosystem; the islands and their waters house thousands of species, a quarter of which exist nowhere else in the world. President Bill Clinton, using an executive order, created a marine reserve there. Mr. Bush is now poised to formalize and strengthen that designation using a law that allows the creation of marine sanctuaries -- a kind of underwater national park. If he does it right, he will create one of the largest marine protected areas in the world and establish a strong precedent for future designations of marine areas as off-limits to human exploitation. If he does it wrong, it will be a huge missed opportunity.
Commercial use of these waters is mercifully limited already -- one of the reasons they remain in fairly good shape and the major reason as well that the sanctuary designation is uncontroversial. Still, a small number of commercial fishermen are active in the region, raising the question of how protected this marine sanctuary will be. Will it be an area set aside for wildlife and no competing human interests? Or will it be an area in which conservation has to jockey with resource extraction and other commercial activity? The fishery in question is not lucrative, yet managers of regional fisheries are pushing hard to preserve access to any future sanctuary anyway. Whether the administration will propose this in its draft plan for the area remains up in the air. In a January letter to the regional fisheries council, federal officials outlined three possibilities: allowing fishing to continue for five years, until 2025, or indefinitely.
The oceans are under enormous stress; overfishing is one predominant cause, and these areas are national treasures. If a large expanse of remote water with limited extant human investment and huge ecological significance does not qualify as a true sanctuary, it will be a sign that the political will to save the oceans just isn't there. On the other hand, if Mr. Bush creates a true sanctuary, he will set a marker for future presidents wishing to protect America's coastal waters."