Re: The CIA's "Prison of Darkness"
stevewonder wrote:oralloy wrote:I should note, since there always seems to be confusion on my position, that since these seem to be low-level detainees, I think it was wrong to torture them.
.
Are saying it would be okay to torture them if they where high level detainess??
Depends on the organization they are in.
Membership in al-Qa'ida results in automatic forfeiture of all human rights in my opinion. Therefore, I see no moral problem with torturing members of al-Qa'ida.
However, there is a practical problem with torture, which is that it results in poor intelligence.
However this downside is offset, in the case of high level detainees, by my enjoyment of their suffering. Therefore I think high level al-Qa'ida detainees should be tortured non-stop.
High level detainees from another organization (say high level Iraqi detainees) should
not be tortured. We should only be torturing members of al-Qa'ida.