@engineer,
engineer wrote:
Brandon9000 wrote:
Assault weapons could be useful to citizens in situations that really might occur, such as a home invasion or to rebel against a dictatorial government.
Experts in firearms are pretty much in agreement that a weapon that shoots through the target, then through the adjacent wall and into the next room are not appropriate for self defense during a home invasion. And it's an extremist fantasy that people are going to rise up against a tyrannical government to defend the constitution.
You guys just love to greatly outnumber someone, don't you? That's the liberal's standard method of fighting. I salute your great courage in joining a group of people already arguing with me. I guess I'll just have to kick your asses one by one. So, at the moment, I will argue with you and only you. When you're done, maybe I'll move on to someone else.
First of all, I note that you don't cite any of these experts. Now, you probably can find someone who will say what you claim is the expert opinion, but you can probably find someone who will say virtually anything. If you wanted to give a testimonial type argument, you'd have to poll experts, and even then, testimonials don't prove much. Weapons that fire bullets more quickly than handguns can be expected to be more effective than handguns when outnumbered, as in a home invasion.
You also say, "And it's an extremist fantasy that people are going to rise up against a tyrannical government...." Certainly there are tyrannical governments in the world. Also, there are governments that take more and more power and bully their people. It seems to me to be a bad idea to allow our government to disarm us. It also seems to me to be a bad idea to allow our government to allow us only the weakest weapons. However, when you say that it's an extremist fantasy, are you saying that it's impossible for a government to become tyrannical, or are you saying that you think it's impossible that the citizens could defend themselves? If, the latter, I'm sure the idea that citizens would be helpless against a tyranny upsets you as it does me, so what would be your solution for people to resist a tyrannical government?