Reply
Sat 23 Jul, 2005 10:02 am
I was wondering if anyone can help me with some legal advice. I was in class at the college Thursday night and while participating, I fell and broke my ankle. I have no insurance since I will begin my student teaching on August 1st. The school is saying that they are not responsible because of the type of accident that it was. I am wondering if I should seek legal advice to help with the medical bills.
More information needed. Was this a dance class or did you fall off your chair?
How was the school responsible for your injury? That's what you have to point out to the administrators. You say they have already denied responsibility because of the type of accident?? What does that mean?
Did you sign anything that absolved them from responsibility before starting the class?
Take the bills for your injury and ask for an appointment with the Provost of Students or whoever oversees the conditions of the Student Body. Explain to the Provost what you are asking for is shared responsibility, 50-50, 60-40, you decide. You can ask for them to pay the whole bill but that's really unlikely. If the school remains adamant about not paying anything mention that the cost of a lawsuit, including defending one even in Small Claims Courts, would exceed the amount necessary to pay the medical bills and that you are merely trying to save them further trouble and expense.
Then tell them they have ten business days to think it over and send their reply.
Use the ten days to research how to file a Small Claims Suit on your own.
good luck
oh, and thanks for being a teacher.
Joe
This accident happened when participating in a PE class. We all had to teach a lesson on a specified topic. The topic was jumping. The ladies who were teaching this concept chose to have us to an obstacle course that wasn't timed, we just went at our own pace with a group of 3-4 people. Our last obstacle was to leap over a rope that was about a foot off of the ground and when I landed, I dislocated my ankle (about 45 degrees) and I was broken also. It required a trip to the ER (only about a mile). When I say that the school says that they aren't responsible for this type of accident, I took it as, if the basketball goal fell on me and hurt me, then that's their responsibility. They really didn't say much other than that, but I've kept pushing and they filed a claim with the state (I guess the Board of Regents). He told me that this would require an investigation and I told him that they could question me all they wanted and that there was even a video showing what happened. My whole thing is, I am required to participate in this class or I fail. While participating, this freak accident happened and I am now responsible. I feel that we should've had to sign a paper saying that we were responsible for any accidents that may happen in this class, this way the school is definately not held liable.
There is no liability for accidental injury in the absence of negligence.
To state a claim for negligence, the following four essential elements must be proven by the preponderance of the evidence (more likely than not): duty, breach, cause, and damages.
The elements are more fully explained in this article:
Quote:
1. Duty. The defendant must owe a legal duty to the victim. A duty is a legally enforceable obligation to conform to a particular standard of conduct. In personal injury cases, the duty is set by what a "reasonable man of ordinary prudence" would have done.
2. Breach of the duty. The defendant failed to conform to the legal duty. The breach can be either an act or a failure to act.
3. Causation. The breach was the cause of an injury to the victim. The causation does not need to be direct: defendant's act (or failure to act) could begin a continuous sequence of events that ended in plaintiff's injury, a so-called "proximate cause".
4. Injury. There must be an injury. In most cases, there must be a physical or financial injury to the victim.
http://www.rbs2.com/labinj.htm