@Ponderer,
Ponderer wrote:
Incidentally, that story was told by a preacher, and I understood the analogy. The subject was changed to birds getting in a barn through other openings, leaving the door open, birds being to small to open the door, etc.
Oh wait, so you do remember the question, if you suddenly remembered the analogy.
I don't care if a preacher told or made up that story or not. It doesn't mean anything who made it up.
I understand that the farmer is god, and the door is Jesus and people are the birds. For crying out loud that was glaringly obvious.
But, why would the farmer send Jesus (the one who can think like a bird), when he just could have left the barn door ajar and let the birds go in an out as it suited them? The door isn't Jesus, it's thought, and choice. Do I want to go in or not? My choice.
The warmth of the barn wouldn't get out because the door was just ajar, and the creatures already in there were producing heat.
The birds may or may not have entered the barn, even seeing the door was ajar, because quite frankly, even with the cold and the wind, they might have been comfortable enough as they were. I'd guess they were hanging around outside the barn because there were hay seeds on the ground, and manute with bugs and seeds, and that's what they wanted/needed. Not the inside of a dark barn.
The farmer didn't have to waste his time going in and out of the cold himself, annoying the birds by making them fly away from whatever it was they were doing outside the barn (they weren't waiting to get in) and they could, if the door was open slightly, decide for themselves to go in or not.
They didn't need someone who could "think like them" and tell them in bird talk what they were trying to do.
In fact, they could have found any number of small spaces that fit their little bodies, where in fact they would have been warmer by generating their own heat that filled up a small space, than in some drafty old barn that wasn't built for them.
Your preacher wrote/told a really crappy analogy. Anyone who would give it a moments thought could see that.