owlette wrote:I sincerely hope you do NOT think I deliberately posted an incorrect answer. My post was a genuine attempt at solving this LC.... If I was way off the mark, I apologise.
Some people seem to feel that anybody who is willing to put in the effort to calculate the answers somehow
owes them the prize-winning answer. They're wrong; you owe them nothing. You put in the effort, showed all your work, and were willing to accept correction. In my opinion, you have nothing to apologize for.
The 'Lenny' authors, in Round 178 wrote:Gilbert the Gelert farmer (He's a Gelert who happens to be a farmer, not a farmer who grows Gelerts!) has three fields. One field is an equilateral triangle, one field is a circle, and one field is a square. The square field is 75% larger in area than the triangular field, and 50% larger in area than the circular field. In order to completely fence all three of the fields, exactly 4000 metres of fencing is required.
What is the total area of all three fields, in square metres?
Let "A_s" be the area of the square, "A_t" be the area of the triangle, and "A_c" be the area of the circle. Then:
. . . . .Since A_s = 1.75(A_t) = (7/4)A_t,
. . . . .then A_t = (4/7)A_s
. . . . .Since A_s = 1.5(A_c) = (3/2)A_c,
. . . . .then A_c = (2/3)A_s
Let "s" be the length of a side of the square field. Then A_s = s^2, so:
. . . . .A_t = (4/7) s^2
. . . . .A_c = (2/3) s^2
The perimeter P_s of the square is 4s.
The triangle is equilateral. Let "t" be the length of a side of the triangle. Then, by what is known of 30-60-90 triangles (one of which would form half of an equilateral triangle), we know that the height of the triangle is (sqrt[3]/2)t, so the area of the triangle is:
. . . . .A_t = (1/2)(t)((sqrt[3]/2) t)
. . . . .= (sqrt[3]/4) t^2
From our previous area equality, we then get:
. . . . .(sqrt[3]/4)t^2 = (4/7) s^2
. . . . .t^2 = (16/(7sqrt[3])) s^2
. . . . .t = (4s) / sqrt[7sqrt[3]]
Then the perimeter P_t of the triangle is (12s)/sqrt[7sqrt[3]]
Let "r" be the length of the radius of the circle. The area A_c of the circle is given by:
. . . . .A_c = (pi) r^2
From our previous area equality, we then get:
. . . . .(pi) r^2 = (2/3) s^2
. . . . .r^2 = (2/(3pi)) s^2
. . . . .r = (sqrt[2]s) / sqrt[3pi]
Then the perimeter (circumference) P_c of the circle is 2(pi)((sqrt[2]s) / sqrt[3pi]) = sqrt[8pi/3]s.
We are given that the total amount of fencing (thus, the total perimeter, assuming no overlap and no waste) is 4000. Then:
. . . . .4000 = P_s + P_t + P_c
. . . . .= 4s + (12s)/sqrt[7sqrt[3]] + sqrt[8pi/3]s
. . . . .= (4 + 12/sqrt[7sqrt[3]] + sqrt[8pi/3])s
Solving, we get:
. . . . .s = 4000/(4 + 12/sqrt[7sqrt[3]] + sqrt[8pi/3])
We don't need to evaluate this until the very end. Returning now to the area considerations, we get:
. . . . .A_s + A_t + A_c
. . . . .= s^2 + (4/7) s^2 + (2/3) s^2
. . . . .= (1 + 4/7 + 2/3) s^2
. . . . .= (47/21) s^2
Doing all the computations continuously in a calculator, we then get a total area of 334887.567696... square meters. Rounded to the nearest whole number, the answer would be "334888".
Please check my work. Thank you.
Eliz.