Mill's "Harm Principle" a part of His Utilitarianism?

Forums: Philosophy, Morality, Ethics, Utilitarianism, John Stuart Mill
Email this Topic • Print this Page

One of the critiques of classic Utilitarianism (the sort first proposed by Jeremy Bentham) is that it can recommend despicable actions so long as they produce 'the greatest happiness to the greatest number'. For example, if ritually sacrificing a small child brought great happiness to the larger community classic Utilitarianism would say we should do it.

But am I correct in believing John Stuart Mill's 'Harm Principle' influenced his version of Utilitarianism so that it precluded such harmful acts to individuals? In other words Mill's belief that "the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others", acts as a veto on any harmful action deemed morally permissible by classic Utilitarianism?

Topic Stats
Top Replies
Link to this Topic

Type: Question • Score: 0 • Views: 2,392 • Replies: 3

No top replies

@vanvulcj,

The short answer is, "yes, of course."

However, it should be pointed out that Mill's concept of the "Harm Principle" was not apriori. It was the (as he viewed it) inextricable relationship between individual liberty and pleasure that made the "Harm Principal" utilitarian.

1 Reply

I wonder what Utilitarianism would have to say to Sado-Maso practices...
Where is the frontier between Sanity and a troubled mind or culture.
What does Utilitarianism has to say bout Muslim women who alledgly freely embrance opression?

0 Replies

@Razzleg,

Thanks, I asked mainly because of all the detractors of Utilitarianism I've seen complaining that it allows for disastrous results, like the one I mentioned. My reaction has always been "haven't they heard of the 'Harm Principle'?"

In my opinion the Harm Principle is a nice bulwark to prevent such misapplications of classic Utilitarianism. So whenever I speak of Utilitarianism I'm actually referring to Mill's version, but since his HP appeared in "On Liberty" rather than his essay, "Utilitarianism", I wondered if that allowed some to not consider it part of his version of the theory.

0 Replies

Mill's "Harm Principle" a part of His Utilitarianism?

Related Topics

Quick Links

My Account

able2know