@blatham,
Oh yes, the i8 is looking very seductive. If I had to get rid of all my cars and have one, the i8 would probably be it. That may happen. Even with the lift I installed last year, keeping them all in good order is getting old (and so am I).
Yeah, a real shame about the Civic R styling. What I'd really like is a Z3 with the Civic R engine. The post 2008 Z4s are OK on looks but I didn't care for the 'flame styling' on the earlier 4s.. They finally put the turbo i6 in the Z4 but the weight was a whopping 800 lb. more with that retracting hard top. Damn!
There is hope for the upcoming Z5 platform developed with Toyota for the return of the Supra and the Toyota 86 would be great if it had more motor. But of course I agree about 'new'. The psychological hit of virtually 1/3 the value going away on the way home from the dealer is tough to get past.
In used cabrios, I agree with farmer that a Boxter ain't bad, especially if you anty up for the S version. Hope you can find a clean Z3 though, they still make me smile every time I see one.