Arguing Without the Quote Button

Forums: Philosophy, Debate
Email this Topic • Print this Page

As if life wasn't hard enough on me, I find out today that quote buttons don't work in real-life situations.

Try arguing with somebody, then make it harder because that person is an irrational female, and top it off with the fact that the person you are arguing with is your mother. Painfully frustrating situation? Grrr.....

I started a simple debate about whether or not reading books was more intellectual than watching a TV show and she decides on her point of view, digs a trench, and bunkers down so that no matter how much truth and good sense I throw at her she won't budge.

The worst part about it is that she doesn't play by the rules of good conduct. She frequently makes flawed statements and ad hominem arguments but when I try to quote what she said earlier she tells me that she said something different.

If I could only bug the room so that everything she says is on tape, I could easily prove that she said what I heard.

How in the world can I quote someone during a discussion when they won't agree that they said what they said earlier?

Topic Stats
Top Replies
Link to this Topic

Type: Discussion • Score: 1 • Views: 2,438 • Replies: 38

No top replies

You can't sadly. I can't tell you the number of times I've tried.

0 Replies

Re: Arguing Without the Quote Button

Individual wrote:

As if life wasn't hard enough on me, I find out today my mother has finally discovered that I am ascribing false quotes to her

It's a frustration, isn't it. Be aware, though, on a2k, quotes can be altered.

Very Happy

0 Replies

I've been guilty of being on the other side as well, but when I absolutely know I can't remember what it was I said, I make no argument about it, and generally laugh at my own silliness.

0 Replies

Roger, you can still look back to the original post. And if it has been edited, you will at least know that it has.

0 Replies

Listen son, you have learned a valuable lesson. You can not win an arguement with a woman. To even attempt winning an arguement with your Mother is hazardous to your physical and mental health.

In the good old days we kept them in the kitchen or church minding the children, and out of politics. Can you see where we slipped up? Laughing

0 Replies

I think for some people, even taping them won't be enough. Razz

Parents especially.

0 Replies

rufio wrote:

I think for some people, even taping them won't be enough. Parents especially.

Unless of course you tape their mouths shut, and bind their hands. Laughing

Incidentally, I am in no way condoning this. :wink:

0 Replies

Re: Arguing Without the Quote Button

Individual wrote:

As if life wasn't hard enough on me, I find out today that quote buttons don't work in real-life situations.

Try arguing with somebody, then make it harder because that person is an irrational female, and top it off with the fact that the person you are arguing with is your mother. Painfully frustrating situation? Grrr.....

I started a simple debate about whether or not reading books was more intellectual than watching a TV show and she decides on her point of view, digs a trench, and bunkers down so that no matter how much truth and good sense I throw at her she won't budge.

The worst part about it is that she doesn't play by the rules of good conduct. She frequently makes flawed statements and ad hominem arguments but when I try to quote what she said earlier she tells me that she said something different.

If I could only bug the room so that everything she says is on tape, I could easily prove that she said what I heard.

How in the world can I quote someone during a discussion when they won't agree that they said what they said earlier?

This is life - and, I might add, memory is infinitely mutable, and subject to both your, and your mother's, desires aboout what you/the other REALLY said.

Which side were you on? Lemme guess. The side of TV?????

Oh - and Asherman is so gonna suffer.

0 Replies

I will add that, for true humiliation, try arguing with someone for hours on IM - only to read back and find that they really DID concede your point in the first couple of exchanges. Also you then see all the nuances - not to mention actual posts - you missed in their argument - and how often, and how much, they missed the point of what you were saying - and how much, much, much, better you could have argued your case!

0 Replies

Attempting to argue with your mother, when she "knows" that she is right, is like attempting to roll a boulder uphill. It can be done, but not without superhuman effort.

Remember that your mother not only knows which of your buttons to push, but has actually created and installed those buttons. She will use them to make her points.

If you know that you cannot debate with her, why bother? She has the psychological advantage from the getgo. Why is is SO important to you to prove to you mother that you are right?

0 Replies

Er - might he BE right???

Lol!

0 Replies

Re: Arguing Without the Quote Button

roger wrote:

Be aware, though, on a2k, quotes cannot be altered.

Really?

0 Replies

My grandpa gave me this piece of advice when arguing with a woman:
"When you feel like debating with her, keep asking yourself: 'Do I want to be right, or do I want to be in her good graces?'"

You can very much win the argument logically. (the battle)
And very much lose her feelings for you. (the war)

But to win the argument and stay in good graces appear to be nearly impossible?

Ask yourself: How do you feel about someone (male or female) after they have completely dismantled your logic, utterly destroyed and humiliated you in an argument. They won, by any fair account. Still: Do you feel like immediately giving them a lot of love on any level?

When you feel like arguing, keep asking yourself: "Where do I really want to be? Where do I really want to be?" "Do I want to be right, or have a loving day/evening?"

I've found this works wonders. Most arguments with close loved ones aren't worth engaging in.

Thats why I vent and dump all my petty grievances and arguments on this board! Twisted Evil

And I love all of you for allowing me to do that.

0 Replies

Mind you, when you absolutely blow a fella out of the water with your logic and reason, you feel kinda warm....

0 Replies

dlowan wrote:

Mind you, when you absolutely blow a fella out of the water with your logic and reason, you feel kinda warm....

hmmm....good to know, good to know.

Does that mean a guy should put up a flimsy argument, let the woman win, then be ready to head upstairs? Laughing

just asking...

0 Replies

I have started to dislike the quote button here. People insist on quoting reams and reams of, to be polite, stuff. No real life conversation has imbedded quotes in it.

and then you said and then i said and then i referenced and then he said and then i said and then you said and then i said and then he said and now i'm saying this

harrumph

0 Replies

I admire Ashermans bravery and foolishness.

0 Replies

extra medium wrote:

dlowan wrote:
Mind you, when you absolutely blow a fella out of the water with your logic and reason, you feel kinda warm....

hmmm....good to know, good to know.

Does that mean a guy should put up a flimsy argument, let the woman win, then be ready to head upstairs?

just asking...

No.

0 Replies

Oh.

0 Replies

Arguing Without the Quote Button

Related Topics

Quick Links

My Account

able2know