Do we know what gravitation is?

Forums: Science, Physics, Unscientific Claptrap
Email this Topic • Print this Page

No! We have an equation that can be used. But I think nobody really knows whaty gravitation is, where it is coming from, what it is. why it functions as it does.

Anyway, we don't need gravitation to explain the universe! That is for sure!

Topic Stats
Top Replies
Link to this Topic

Type: Discussion • Score: 0 • Views: 1,446 • Replies: 22

No top replies

@Quehoniaomath,

Quote:

Anyway, we don't need gravitation to explain the universe! That is for sure!

Im not so sure Que. In The Whole Shebang by Timothy Ferris by the sheerest coincidence I was reading last night, although "Attempts to write a fully unified supers9ymmetric theory incorporating gravitation….faltered….," nonetheless "Enter superstring theory…might be the way to a fully unified account….that one could not write a string theory without incorporating gravity"

But in answer to your q, gravity is kinda mysterious. Obviously it's a distortion of space, a curved region if you will. I had always thought of it as the matter itself creating the field by "shoving" space out of the way

2 Replies

@dalehileman,

Quote:

m not so sure Que. In The Whole Shebang by Timothy Ferris by the sheerest coincidence I was reading last night, although "Attempts to write a fully unified supers9ymmetric theory incorporating gravitation….faltered….," nonetheless "Enter superstring theory…might be the way to a fully unified account….that one could not write a string theory without incorporating gravity"

But in answer to your q, gravity is kinda mysterious. Obviously it's a distortion of space, a curved region if you will. I had always thought of it as the matter itself creating the field by "shoving" space out of the way

To start with the last, gravity doesn't curve space at all! It is a physical impossibility by its own definition.
Furthermore , if you want, look into the subject of "The Electric Universe"
because that can explain things in the universe much better than gravity does.

And yes, gravity is mysterious because none seems to be able to figure out what it is.

First of all it can'tt be any power or force.

It also has an inverse relation with the speed of light.

1 Reply

@Quehoniaomath,

Quote:

To start with the last, gravity doesn't curve space at all!

Quote:

If gravity is actually curved space and if falling objects are simply following the natural curves of space why does each object have its own curve?

This is a great question which goes to the heart of why Einstein said gravity is the curvature of space-time, rather than just the curvature of space.

http://curious.astro.cornell.edu/question.php?number=649

I'm sure electricity and gravity will prove equally important in the eventual Theory of Everything

1 Reply

@dalehileman,

What are you saying. I am only saying that space can't be 'curved' by its own definition.

1 Reply

@Quehoniaomath,

Que all I know is what I read somewhere

https://www.google.com/?gws_rd=ssl#q=space+is+curved

1 Reply

@dalehileman,

Quote:

Que all I know is what I read somewhere

https://www.google.com/?gws_rd=ssl#q=space+is+curved

Fair enough, so I know where you are coming from.
However being able to google it, doesn't make it true. Wink

Let's put some logic in this nonsense.

Eddigton and other did some experiment with an ecclips. and alledgedly this proved the 'curvature of space"

However, what they didn't tell you is that Eddington 'massaged' the date and
that there are other and better explanations for what happened.

So, alwasy dive under the surface of the stories, that can tell you a lot.
And using logic helps a lot too. If a theory predicts a cetrain outcome, and we get that outcome, doesn't mean the theory is right of course.
A mistake that is made a lot in what people used to call 'science'.

Furthermore, Einstein was a thief and a plagiarist, he has stolen his ideas from others!

But let's stick with 'curved space'.

Aside from the flawed and dishonest experiment, 'curved space' is an impossibility.

Just look at the definition of 'space' itself!

0 Replies

And a lot of this nonsense is based on mathematics. (tensor equations and what have you)

But mathematics is very unreliable at this point, especally differential equations and calculus!

(see my other thread about this topic that mathematic is very flawed)

So, you see, lots and lots and lots of problems with it!

0 Replies

Gravitation as a "force" still is the best explanation ever given. Observation in general backs up gravitation as a force.

On the other hand, the curved space and similar fiction garbage are solely ideas invented by a poor lunatic called Albert Einstein.

His theories have been proven false and survive thanks to the insistence of some dudes who can't accept that they were so idiots to believe in such fantasies, and also thanks to the pride of a certain ethnic group.

The Theory Everything is pushed by relativists, because their theory has been mixed with the rest to survive. You set apart relativity and do a public scrutiny on it confronting relativists, and everybody will find out that relativity is crap to the square.

The simplicity of Newton's definition of gravity works and is observable. If you don't agree with it, then show me your curved space.

2 Replies

@carloslebaron,

Quote:

Gravitation as a "force" still is the best explanation ever given. Observation in general backs up gravitation as a force.

On the other hand, the curved space and similar fiction garbage are solely ideas invented by a poor lunatic called Albert Einstein.

His theories have been proven false and survive thanks to the insistence of some dudes who can't accept that they were so idiots to believe in such fantasies, and also thanks to the pride of a certain ethnic group.

The Theory Everything is pushed by relativists, because their theory has been mixed with the rest to survive. You set apart relativity and do a public scrutiny on it confronting relativists, and everybody will find out that relativity is crap to the square.

The simplicity of Newton's definition of gravity works and is observable. If you don't agree with it, then show me your curved space.

I agree 'curved space' ia nonsense! Of course it is! However,. I disagree gravitiy being a force. That is also not possible!

0 Replies

@carloslebaron,

Quote:

curved space and similar fiction garbage

Carl I'd have to take your word for it. But it's always been my understanding that viewed from a distance, a traveler in a gravitational field would appear to be following a curve in spite of the travelers' instruments assuring him he's proceeding in a straight line

How've I been misled

1 Reply

@dalehileman,

Quote:

Carl I'd have to take your word for it. But it's always been my understanding that viewed from a distance, a traveler in a gravitational field would appear to be following a curve in spite of the travelers' instruments assuring him he's proceeding in a straight line

How've I been misled

Maybe he does,, maybe he doesn't! It isn't even proved yet!

But 'curved space' can't exist! anywhere!!!!

Doesn't exist! Nowhere!

1 Reply

@dalehileman,

How is gravity a distortion of space? I have seen the speculation that gravity can be the cause of space distortion, however the distortion is not itself gravity.

1 Reply

@Quehoniaomath,

Quote:

Maybe he does,, maybe he doesn't! It isn't even proved yet!

Golly Que I remember many reports of telescopic sighting where the path of a free-falling object is seen to be slightly deflected as it passes a large body

Was I dreaming

1 Reply

@DNA Thumbs drive,

Quote:

How is gravity a distortion of space?

DNA we seem to be getting into semantics

1 Reply

@dalehileman,

Not at all, unless you are speculating that gravity and space are the same thing.

1 Reply

@dalehileman,

Quote:

Golly Que I remember many reports of telescopic sighting where the path of a free-falling object is seen to be slightly deflected as it passes a large body

Was I dreaming

Yes, the light might be deflected. So???? I still stand behind what I wrote.
You left a lot out here.

But 'curved space' can't exist! Nowhere!

0 Replies

@DNA Thumbs drive,

Quote:

Not at all, unless you are speculating that gravity and space are the same thing.

No, I imagine gravity a condition of space as the sneeze is a quality of the humanoid

1 Reply

@dalehileman,

Excellent answer, however it has little meaning, as the human mind has an almost unlimited power to imagine the unreal.

http://www.cuded.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/Imaginary-Foundation_8600_466.jpg

1 Reply

@DNA Thumbs drive,

Quote:

Excellent answer,

Why thanks DNA

Quote:

however it has little meaning,

Then maybe not exactly excellent

Quote:

as the human mind has an almost unlimited power to imagine the unreal.

Yes, almost. For instance it can't easily imagine the Universe expanding without visualizing in the mind's eye a void that doesn't exist

But thanks DNA for that beautiful illustration

1 Reply

Do we know what gravitation is?

Related Topics

Quick Links

My Account

able2know