@cicibebe,
cicibebe wrote:
Also it's fun to point out that Nietzsche, their favorite philosopher, was a complete loner who had sex once, but still managed to get AIDS right before going batshit insane.
Plus just because there isn't an obvious answer to the meaning of life doesn't mean one doesn't exist.
And, the only humans who have the right to exist are the Ubermensch, characterized by not being fat, ugly, virgin basement-dwellers. Furthermore, Nietzsche was gloating sadist to believe the Übermensch should destroy the parasitic humans.
Can you disprove all things I said? I don't think so.
Actually, you've made a number of erroneous statements. Besides the historically inaccurate, and irrelevant, point regarding the cause of Nietzsche's madness, it should also be made clear that Nietzsche, while in his philosophical prime, regarded his philosophy as the antithesis of a nihilist position. He regarded Platonism (and its "modern" idealist derivatives) as representatives of nihilism, and his philosophy as the "cure". In his view, the subjects of his criticism preferred an unapproachable ideal to the complex, "impure" reality before them. He sought to embrace the experiences presented to him, rather than deny it and pursue the untouchable.
Nihilists that elect Nietzsche as their heresiarch do so by fundamentally misunderstanding his thought; similarly, you do the same by holding him responsible for their reactions. Both of you make the mistake of viewing his iconoclasm as nihilism.
Re: "just because there isn't an obvious answer to the meaning of life doesn't mean one doesn't exist": Nietzsche would have wholeheartedly agreed. In fact, he would have insisted that the person who does not require a "reason" for living, is the person who most fully exercises and endures "existence." On the other hand, he probably would have disdained any "reason to live", being alive was itself enough reason to live.
And as for your characterization of the idea of the Übermensch as the right to be the ultimate bully -- that is very disingenuous. Nietzsche meant to use the ideal of the Übermensch to imply and implement the idea that individuals, as well as humankind at large, are capable of overcoming what he perceived as their weaknesses, both physical and psychological -- not to encourage the exploitation of the weaknesses of others.
It's easy to disprove the things that you have said -- all i have to do is read the source material. Why don't you give it a try?