@Lustig Andrei,
Lustig Andrei wrote:My point, David, is that the word "mystery"
implies a great deal more than just missing information.
Maybe; not necessarily;
e.g., will u admit that bookstores r replete
with "mysteries" involving fictional murders,
based upon human inter-action?? Maybe love-triangles?
If the author
earns the price of his book,
B4 it is over, he has provided his reader with all of the initially absent information,
so that everything is lucidly explained ("I did this because he did that")
such that there no longer exists any mystery. Do u agree with that??
Lustig Andrei wrote:It implies that there is information which is not known and which is, perhaps, unknowable.
It is vaguely used to mean that,
oblivious to the logic that if & when the additional information
is acquired, then there will no longer be a mystery; e.g., for many years,
I was under the impression that no one knew what was on the other side of human death.
That was B4 it was published (in the 1970s) that many people had come back to life in hospitals
(especially after defibrillation) and
TOLD us.
For
many years (like all of human history and
pre-history)
it was a mystery what was on the far side of the Moon.
Then in the 1960s,
we WENT THERE and looked down;
that was the abrupt end of the mystery. It was no longer
"unknowable" as u put it.
Lustig Andrei wrote:It is not "missing" in the sense that it can be discovered with a little effort.
If that is the case, there is no actual mystery, merely an unsolved problem.
YES; unsolved because of incomplete information.
The
MYSTERY cannot survive arrival of the rest of the information which explains it.
Lustig Andrei wrote:A mystery implies something much deeper.
It only seems spooky as long as we remain
IGNORANT.
Another way to put the same point
is that
MYSTERY is made out of
IGNORANCE.
David