@hawkeye10,
True, there is no problem, but your point brings us back to the original question or to state it another way, if almost all the players on the tour are similar to the Williams sisters, so why do some become "darlings of women's tennis"?
Let's look at Justine Henin who gets such glowing accolades at the start of your article. Henin dethroned Serena Williams and became number one. Of course she was well known in the US, but in Europe, she was a big deal with Belgium and France both claiming some ownership. At 5'6", she is presents a striking contrast to the larger players on the tour, has the best backhand in tennis and was racking up big numbers. Is this who you would like to represent women's tennis? I mean the press likes her even though... she cheats, looking for coaching from the stands. She demonstrates poor sportsmanship, once claiming a stomach injury with one game left in the Australian Open championship instead of letting her opponent finish the match out. (The Williams sisters are not the most sportsmanlike either.) From the number one position, carrying the banner of women's tennis, she quit the game for a couple of years significantly harming the tour. The Williams selectively manage their schedule, but they don't quit and they show at the big tournaments (with the exception of Indian Wells which we've discussed already). Of course, Henin is back now, but not in form, but everyone is cheering her comeback.
You mention the tall, blond and that typically means Sharapova. Sharapova also cheats, getting coaching during the match. Because she can't manage her schedule and plays everything in sight, she is often injured, missing big tournaments and doing harm to the tour. That doesn't stop her from endorsing everything in sight of course. You are correct that many people will see her on the court and cheer for the leggy blond but her versus Serena, I am pulling for Serena every time. Serena has never cheated. She is an athlete playing want to be models.
So why do players become the darlings of women's tennis? Davenport was well liked because of her philanthropy, her willingness to work with children, her accessibility to the fans, etc. and she put up big numbers on the court but she was never a darling. Was that because she wasn't particularly beautiful? Was it because she wasn't particularly controversial? Same with Clisters. Both Davenport and Clisters dropped from the tour, had children and came back. Does that spoil the image for some people? To quote from the same article you posted:
Quote:This is a basic truth about the Williamses, held among professional watchers of the sport as well as players. Venus says it herself: “Serena and I did change the game, and it’s interesting to see people on court now trying to do all our moves. To be that person, the one who changed the game, wow, that’s too good to be true.”
Why don't such revolutionary figures get the love? Maybe it has nothing to do with race or beauty. Maybe we hate revolutionaries at heart.
The Williams sisters are as deserving of admiration from the press and the public as any player on the women's tour, probably more deserving than most. Your quote notes that Venus has been an unofficial player rep to the tour for years. Hopefully their independent streak, their willingness to tell the tour that they must balance the needs of the tour against the needs of the players will revolutionize the game, but with the disdain of the casual public, I think they will likely just be iconoclastic players and when they're gone the tour will go back to destroying young players in the quest for more money and more flash. The article you posted in interesting because it talks about how unusual it is that the power balance has shifted so that the Williams sisters have the ability to talk back to the tour. I think having a balance between the players and the tour is a good thing. The tour has demonstrated over the over that they do not take into account the needs of the players and are only focused on their bottom line. We need more players like the Williams sisters, but I doubt we'll see them anytime soon.