@jeeprs,
jeeprs;139409 wrote:Something that we should not loose sight of in all the debates about religion and its place in society is that of religion as a spiritual culture.
In Buddhism, one of the words for meditation is 'bhavana' which literally means 'becoming'. This recognizes the fact that the way you think ultimately determines what you become. 'As you think, so you become' is actually a good starting point for any consideration of the nature of spiritual culture. It is a universal principle which is simple to understand, but which has many consequences.
Now the difference between spiritual culture and religion is that it is practical, rather than a 'belief system'. You will notice in many of the debates about religion, many big statements and questions about the nature of reality, science and religion, whether there is a God or not, and so on, are constantly being made. It is very easy for these debates to have a very polarizing influence on those involved - you will be driven one way or the other, to belief or non-belief, and into many dichotomies and dualities.
Religion as spiritual culture has a different approach. It is based on cultivation of states of calmness, clarity and insight, through meditation. This is something that can be experienced and tested. It is not a dogmatic belief system. Buddhism is very well known for this, but such an approach is not only Buddhist. Other Indian philosophy and Yoga schools teach this approach, and (believe it or not) it is also quite possible for both Christians and those who are not 'religiously committed' to any belief to adopt this approach.
Such a practice generally does rely on an ethical code, such as abandoning or reducing intoxicants, moderation in speech and behaviour - the very basic moral and ethical guidelines which are common to many religions and philosophies, although it can also be seen as a "common-sense" approach to life.
Establishing a regular meditation practice is the center of this outlook. Silent meditation, even for brief periods of time, provides new perspectives on the problems of life, who we are, and how our minds and bodies interact. Meditation requires some self-discipline and persistence, but over time it gives rise to an ever-deepening sense of the joy of life and a place of calmness in the center of the being.
So let's not forget that this type of spiritual culture is an important and beneficial practice. Speaking from experience, when meditation begins to work its magic in your life, your appreciation of the meaning of many things begins to change, and life itself seems a lot less of a battle. There are many other benefits, and many ways of practicing, which produce long-term benefits and new horizons. It is a long-term commitment, and, as said, a form of spiritual culture - but one well worth pursuing.
Just for clarity, it seems that you are speaking of a type of religion that is different from what is usually meant by the term "religion". You are calling this type of religion "spiritual culture".
On the one hand, "Religion",
in the usual sense of the word, refers to a set of
beliefs, usually including beliefs about God or gods, a story of how the world or universe came into being, a specific moral code, beliefs about the afterlife, beliefs about the nature of reality, the soul, the spirit, etc. Along with these beliefs, "religion" in the usual sense, often includes various practices, rituals, hierarchy of clerics, temples or other edifices, etc.
On the other hand, the sense of the word "religion" that you ae discussing,
religion as a spiritual culture, has very little of the baggage of the usual sense. Some may even question whether what you are talking about even qualifies as a religion by any definition of the term. Your concept of
religion as a spiritual culture can claim to be religion only insofar as it may have something to do with spirituality. Even that claim may be irrelevant insofar as it can be argued that meditation is a form of mental exercise which improves mental health, just as physical exercise improves physical health. The 'ethical code' you refer to are related to improved mental health as well: abandoning or reducing use of intoxicants, moderation (i.e. exercising self control) in speech and behavior which, as you say, "can also be seen as a 'common-sense' approach to life."
I have no doubt there is much to be gained from meditation, either with or without spiritual and/or religious beliefs, but I am not sure that what you are calling
religion as a spiritual culture can claim to be called religion in any sense.