Tina Turner looked like a girl any family would want to hire as a babysitter while Eminem seemed desperately in need of a square meal. Prince actually looked masculine in high school. Madonna looked wholesome and clean cut and scrubbed.
The big surprises for me were Ryan Secrest, Marily Manson and Steven Tyler, Avril Levigne...actually almost every single one of them. None of them started out looking as I'd have pictured them.