@hawkeye10,
hawkeye10 wrote:
Quote:Since I am not Black, I do not see how I can comment on the merits, or lack of merits, of an African-American holiday. Who am I to judge whether the reasons for developing the holiday are valid?
You are a member of a more important group, the entire human race. You are a stake holder in the human race, thus you have grounds to make value judgements on what any individual or subgroup does, as well as the right to take action against it/them if it is needed to promote the best interests of the human race.
Your point above can be argued in an Ethics course. I take the position that since some people subscribe primarily to their ethnicity and/or race, rather than primarily on the universal aspect of being a human, I do not think I have the right to stand in judgement of anyone's definition of themselves.
Also, why does anyone voice an opinion against Kwanzaa? It is a holiday that has as much positive aspects as any other holiday, I believe. Any concerns about Chanukah? That commemorates a battle against the ancient Assyrians (Greeks in those days). I would guess some people could wonder how that is getting equal billing, in some regions, to Christmas greetings. Is that sort of incongruous - Peace on Earth and Victory over the Assyrians?
I will now go back to minding my own business.