Barack Obama's campaign finds a culture clash in Philadelphia
The city's entrenched, quirky political system isn't a natural fit for a campaign staff that talks grass-roots. And what's this about no cash payouts?
Los Angeles Times
April 20, 2008
NEW KID IN TOWN: Max Stahl, 19, stands in the Obama campaign office he runs in the Germantown area of Philadelphia.
Hal Sawyer figures he knows just what is needed to deliver his precinct for Barack Obama in the gritty world of Philadelphia politics.
He has rigged up his Dodge Caravan with a loudspeaker so he can drive through his neighborhood in northwest Philadelphia urging people to come out to Obama events. He has reams of contacts as a local committeeman, part of the city's entrenched Democratic Party machine.
So when Sawyer walked into an Obama campaign office and asked for a yard sign, the response took him aback. They said they didn't have any.
"Then I tried to play the 'I'm a Democratic committeeman' card and 'I need materials for my voters and stuff for election day.' And their response was nothing, zero. 'You're a what?' "
The mutual puzzlement underscores the culture clash within the coalition working to elect Obama here. In the run-up to the Pennsylvania primary Tuesday, there is a deep divide over the best tactics to use in this city's quirky political culture.
On one side is the city's aging Democratic apparatus, a collection of pro-Obama ward leaders and committee people whose tools of persuasion are yard signs, campaign hats, buttons, stickers and "street money" -- cash handed out before the election to juice turnout.
On the other is the Obama campaign team, a network of young aides from out of state who eschew the traditional trappings of a campaign and think that elections turn on intangibles: grass-roots organization and an ever-expanding web of volunteers motivated by a deep belief in the candidate.
The Obama camp isn't bent on planting signs in every yard. Nor is it paying street money to party bosses in hopes that they'll get people to the polls. Instead, the campaign wants to build an efficient and more loyal apparatus by enlisting volunteers who have one agenda: an Obama victory.
'A brand new approach'
One hot spot in this uneasy alliance is a stretch of northwest Philadelphia that includes a section known as Germantown. The area spans two wards and is home to 29,000 registered Democratic voters -- about 4% of the citywide total. A diverse part of the city, the neighborhood includes grand 19th century Victorian houses and abandoned row homes.
Although Democratic rival Hillary Rodham Clinton is ahead in statewide polls, this territory favors Obama. Both wards endorsed him. The only question on election day is how big the Obama vote will be. Will voters turn out in numbers that pump up his margin in Philadelphia, helping him overcome Clinton's advantage in older, blue-collar parts of the state?
The Obama campaign is betting that its get-out-the-vote operation, and the theory that underpins it, will prevail even in an older city like Philadelphia that still practices machine politics. But the political leadership here is watching with dismay and growing resentment.
"They have paid college kids coming to our community and trying to get us to volunteer -- for them, not with them," said Greg Paulmier, 49, the neighborhood ward leader for the last 14 years. "We have a whole organization here. In some respect they're trying to work with us, but they're working with us on their terms. This is a brand new approach that I'm not familiar with."
For the Obama campaign, the territory is under the control of a 19-year-old college student, Max Stahl.
A Massachusetts native taking a year off from school, Stahl is committed to the Obama view of field work. The ring tone on his cellphone is the John Lennon song "Power to the People." He sees his job as recruiting volunteers to do the hard and unglamorous work of getting Obama elected: knocking on doors in hopes of coaxing voters to the polls.
Standing outside the campaign office in Germantown, Stahl complained that Paulmier wasn't working hard enough for the candidate.
"Greg's not making calls quick enough to committee people," Stahl told Sawyer on a recent afternoon. "He said he made 'a few.' I'll take that to mean zero."
Stahl, whose curly black hair sticks out from under an Obama baseball cap, has little use for the yard signs that many Philadelphians covet. The real value in such swag is that it may entice people to volunteer.
One afternoon last week, a woman came into the Germantown office to pick up a couple of campaign buttons for her mother. By the time she left, she had agreed to volunteer.
A man walked in, motorcycle helmet in hand, looking for a sticker to put on his bike. Would he be willing to volunteer? (No, he said.)
Someone called the office and asked for a ticket to the Obama rally on Independence Mall. The volunteers in the office replied that there was a "preferred seating" ticket available in exchange for -- volunteering.
"If this were a yard sign primary, Hillary Clinton would have won South Carolina and Iowa big-time," said Stahl, dressed in a T-shirt, jeans and sweatshirt. "We're focused on different things. We're focused on talking to people and getting them out to vote."
Trouble is, Philadelphians may like Obama, but they also like what a well-funded campaign can give.
Speaking of the young Obama workers, Sawyer said: "To them, hats, yard signs and T-shirts are out of the Stone Age. They're about the Internet, cellphones and BlackBerrys. It's all digital, conceptual and theoretical. But people here want stuff. . . . They want T-shirts and hats and buttons."
He points to an Obama button on his shirt. "They want these buttons!"
A mystifying move
And they want money.
For decades, candidates have passed money to city ward bosses, who in turn give it out to the committee people and party loyalists under their jurisdiction. Called street money, it is used for any number of purposes. In its most noble form, it reimburses people for gas, coffee or other legitimate expenses rung up on election day.
But even the system's proponents acknowledge the cash payouts are occasionally abused.
"I bet in those neighborhoods where things are harder you'll find the street money doesn't get used the way it should be," said Dock Brown, 43, a Democratic Party committeeman who lives in Germantown. "It just gets pocketed. You'll find people working both campaigns trying to make as much money as they can."
The Obama campaign has told the local ward bosses they're not paying out street money this year, a position that has stirred criticism. At a time when Obama is pulling in tens of millions of dollars in campaign money every month, the city's ward bosses are mystified. They know he can afford it.
"Maybe in other parts of the country you can come in and you have people who are not really into politics and they're excited about working for a candidate, but Philadelphia is not one of those places," said Betty Townes, a committeewoman from Germantown.
"This is old-time politics here."
Donna Reed Miller, a city councilwoman and a ward leader from northwest Philadelphia, said: "There are many people who, because of poverty rates here in Philadelphia and unemployment rates, see election day as a way to make a few extra dollars. And I don't see anything wrong with that. When people read in the paper that you've raised a lot of money, they're wondering why they can't be paid on election day."
Ward leaders supporting Clinton said they had been told that her campaign, which is not as well funded, would pay a select number of local foot soldiers a fee for working election day.
Obama supporters think he should at least do the same. But the campaign is digging in, on the theory that conventional rules of politics don't apply. In Obama, they think they have the rare sort of candidate who can bring people to the polls without financial inducements.
Jeremy Bird, the campaign's Pennsylvania field director, said the campaign faced a similar predicament in South Carolina, a state that Obama won easily.
"We always said that we're not going to do politics the way it's always been done because it's always been done that way," Bird said. "In South Carolina, the kind of politics that have always been done there -- give some money to ministers and to some people on election day -- to me is disempowering. Why not build a real grass-roots [model]?"
With its tradition of street money and election day spoils, Philadelphia is posing perhaps the toughest test for the Obama field strategy.
Sawyer tells of driving around in his Dodge one day, using the loudspeakers strapped to the roof to recruit volunteers. One person was interested but didn't seem to get that volunteers don't get paid.
"A guy yells at me: 'How much?' "