@farmerman,
I don't think you understood my point. They are very different issues from a matter of conservation. But msolga isn't concerned with conservation specifically, she wants no whales to be killed
period.
So I recognize that there is a very different issue of sustainability (which is my own main concern about whaling) my comparison was to the emotional side of msolga's argument, which is that it's a pity to kill such intelligent and beautiful creatures and that this should not be done.
My point was that pigs are intelligent and their fate in an abattoir is not pretty, and a similar appeal to emotion can be made there. Many cultures are appalled by what another culture eats (quite frankly almost everything Japanese people eat I can't handle, including whale and all sea food) but unless there is a legitimate issue of resource conservation I don't think they should be allowed to dictate what animals are fair game.
The issue of whaling started with a legitimate issue of species conservation and the International Whaling Commission was created with the mission of creating the conditions for
sustainable whaling. It has since morphed into an anti-whaling organization because of nations who are appalled by the concept of killing whales altogether.
I don't do sea food, but Japan's land dictates that they do. And Southpark again expressed this culture conflict nicely when at the end of their whaling episode Japanese are converted into "normal" people who no longer hate whales and dolphins but now hate cows and pigs like us.
My point about our eats not being pretty is that this is an inordinate emotional attachment to one animal, and that cultures that kill animals like pigs are hypocritical to advocate such animal rights only for animals they aren't interested in eating themselves.