I'm not sure this info will be useful to anyone, as I may be the only one renting these films, but just in case you were wondering...
D+
I like Hilary Duff movies and though the title gave it away, you would think there would be some sort of twist or "added plot" to make it different from the 100 other Cinderella Story.
She always gets these "super innocent roles" which normally are okay, but this one did not fit. Tried way too hard to be the overlooked beauty that wasn't cool. Not a good fit since from the start, she came off as the likeable high school student w/good looks.
I feel better now that I've shared.