spendius wrote:Mac wrote-
1- The equating a cigarette with a smouldering refuse tip was underhand and a lie.
I was comparing the smell of the hair, clothes and person of a smoker with someting very unpleasant. That is not a lie, it is true. But I may have permitted myself some dramatic licence to get your attention. Worked, too.
Quote:
2- That you abuse our trust by finding an incident involving a "heavy" smoker and even then blithely assuming that the problem reported by a member of the claque was caused by that and not something else just on his/her sayso.
So? Medical evidence shows that the detrimental effects of just about every ailment are made worse by smoking.
Quote:
3- That you have no proof that passive smoking does anybody any harm and that it is a lie to assert, on no scientific evidence, that it does.
Steve has spoken to that. Roy Castle.
Quote:
4- That '14-'18 soldiers, airmen and sailors would have despised these fear-raddled do-gooders freaking out at the aroma of tobacco smoke.
Opinion. Times change, and habits too as new evidence comes to the fore. But irrelevant
Quote:
5- That this fear is often faked in order to gain power to officiously order everybody about in humiliating circumstances.
Partly true, but if you think that is what the Government are doing, bear in mind they are bringing about a huge drop in tax revenues. Now why would they choose to do that, if the advantages did not outweigh the disadvantages?
Quote:
6- That they won't go away now they have this victory.
"They" may be your best friends
Quote:
7- That smoking deaths, through abuse mainly, are much cheaper for the NHS than the long drawn out declines of people into their 80s and 90s.
Smoking banned extends useful lives. Rejoice.
Quote:
8- That non smokers get fat and obese and present the NHS with another set of difficulties.
Let's jump one fence at a time
Quote:
9- That non-smokers are crap company.
I've seen this stated before. It may be true. But smokers are smelly company.
Quote:
10- That nicotine inhibits degenerative brain disease and stimulates creativity which we need to prosper.
That's a new one on me, and probably not true. Users of other narcotics who wish to stimulate their brains (Coleridge, Byron) usually don't do it for long.
Quote:
11- That candlelit dining out should be outlawed on your own arguments along with a lot of other stuff.
Let's take a vote on that one. I vote for occasional candlelit dinners.
Quote:
12- That passive driving has killed and maimed millions of people for sure and thus unauthorised driving should be banned forthwith.
Unauthorised driving IS banned.
Quote:13- That your excessive concern for our health is a club to beat us with and actually you don't give a shite and that if you do give a shite but not for victims of passive bargain hunting in the sweatshops of the world then you are objectively a dyed-in-the-wool racist and value human life on a sliding scale with yours at 100 and a coolie on zero.
My concern is for my health, and the pleasantness of my surroundings.
Mr Brown's concern is for all of us, even the miserable gits.
Quote:
14- That the ban is an attack on freedom.
It is, but what sort of freedom if that? I don't have the freedom to piss in your soup, even though you have no proof that it will do you any harm.
Any more?