Mac wrote-
Quote:Behaviour of Brits, very poor, nay criminal.
Not at all Mac. You're making an error of judgement based on your need to look kind and considerate.
They were men at war a long way from home. They were scared. They were young. They were mostly illiterate. They hadn't had the benefit of a liberal education. They were scared of the officers too and the officers were scared of them. Not so much of dying or even getting injured as being captured. The others were dancing in the salons having a gay old time. Not a care in the world.
What would you expect? They didn't underestimate their enemies. And it's no good saying that they shouldn't have been enemies. They were enemies. What should and shouldn't be was decided in London and they didn't have mobile phones. They were out on a limb. They had heard of expeditionary forces never been seen again.
Do you think you would have been much different in all the circumstances?
It was hot. No white ladies for 5000 miles. No beer. Sand in your crack. Roasting game on a twig fire. Water shortage and what there was had been pissed in by a range of furry creatures. Funny noises all night. Mites in the hard-tack. Mosquitos. Spade strapped to your back plus another 80lbs. Boots chafing. All day- all night. Non-stop. At the ends of the earth.
And you are taking your opinion from off a cut and paste job off telly which has an agenda. The people who made it have never been in such situations as those they were at some pains to try to depict. Sifting through the juicy bits to find the juiciest and get the Titchmarch whine going and all of a sudden you and dadpad are angelic little tweeters.
Go and have a blow-wave in the unisex.
Anyway- it's libel to call somebody "criminal" until after they've been convicted. Suppose you met a wrestler who is the great grandson of one of those guys and had all his medals in a showcase on the sideboard and his letters home in a drawer.