Thomas wrote:georgeob1 wrote: The bureaucrats in the government agancies may have another idea, but once the political issues become clear, I believe the Poles will get their way. The EU is another matter.
From Walter's article, it actually seems as if "the bureaucrats in the government agencies" like the idea of visa waivers for the Poles. The highest hurdle, according to the article, seems to be the "get tough on immigration" wing of Congress Republicans.
I checked this out and you are indeed correct, Thomas. Certainly the Bush administration has created a close relationship with Poland and also wishes to push this. The anti immigration-wing of the Republican Party is mostly WASP - they didn't like the Irish or the Italians either. (They also have the wrong target in mind: we should instead impose visa requirements on the French and Belgians.) However this wing of the Republican Party doesn't count for much political force overall: most Republicans favor continued immigration, but with better border & residency controls. The Democrats are also involved in the anti immigration bit, - some of their prioviledged minority constituents are not too fond of the social and economic competition they encounter from immigrants - same goes for the Unions (which provide about 40% of Democrat funds).
The fact is we will not shut down or unduly restrict immigration, though we will undoubtedly do a better (or less bad) job of enforcing our residency laws, I'm in Boston doing one of those short courses at HBS - my taxi driver coming in from Logan airport was from Sudan, but as he explained to me "I'm an American" - and he's correct - a hard-working guy who has been here for five years and has a family. (Interesting to note that the majority of the class here is from Europe or Asia -- surprisingly lots of Dutch & Irish, and, of course English & Chinese.)