Physical books vs. E-readers: Has anyone actually made a permanent switch and never looked back?

Forums: Hobbies, Technology, Books
Email this Topic • Print this Page

I know this is a classic debate, but I'm curious about the 'point of no return.' I love the smell and feel of real books, but the convenience of an e-reader is undeniable.

For those who bought an e-reader years ago, do you still buy physical books, or has your bookshelf just become a dust collector? What tipped the scale for you?

Topic Stats
Top Replies
Link to this Topic

Type: Question • Score: 6 • Views: 384 • Replies: 11

No top replies

I've bought just one ebook. I prefer the paper books for a variety of reasons. I love to have them in my hands. I like to be able to access them even when offline. Most importantly, I feel there will eventually be a huge shutdown and loss of the entire internet as we know it. Physical books could be the lone survivors.

1 Reply

@cmturner,

That’s a profound perspective, especially the point about a potential internet shutdown. It’s something we rarely think about in our hyper-connected world, but physical books really are the ultimate decentralized backup of human knowledge. I love that you brought that up!

I totally get the appeal of having a tangible book in your hands—there's a sense of permanence there that a file just can't replicate. That said, I still find myself torn because carrying a whole library in a pocket is so tempting for travel.

Out of curiosity, for the paper books you cherish the most, do you actively look for special/hardcover editions, or is it purely about the content and the physical survival of the book?

1 Reply

@Paul260408,

I have read the paperback and then bought it in hardback. Examples: Ulysses by Joyce, and several by Philip Wylie.

I don't object to online reading, so long as physical books get their due.

1 Reply

@cmturner,

cmturner wrote:

I have read the paperback and then bought it in hardback. Examples: Ulysses by Joyce, and several by Philip Wylie.

I don't object to online reading, so long as physical books get their due.

Here's an edit to my post: I bought a ragged old copy of Ulysses from a used book store. So it was hardback, but too awful to keep.

0 Replies

I prefer physical books but I'm at a stage in my life I'm really try to limit the accumulation of more stuff. I have a cheap tablet that I use to download books in the public domain from Project Gutenberg and borrow newer books from Archive.org. But there are some books that I'll always prefer to thumb through, write notes in the margins, use multiple bookmarks, underline brilliant passages, and let drop to the floor when I close my eyes.

1 Reply

@hightor,

The way you described closing your eyes and letting the book drop to the floor is so beautifully poetic—that’s a feeling a tablet can never replicate!

I really admire your approach. Using a cheap tablet for public domain and borrowed books is a brilliant way to prevent 'clutter guilt' while saving the physical shelf space for the books that genuinely matter. It feels like the perfect modern compromise between minimalism and a love for reading.

Since you love writing in the margins and underlining brilliant passages, do you ever find yourself going back to reread those specific notes years later? Or is the act of writing them down just about processing the book in that exact moment?

2 Replies

@Paul260408,

Quote:

...do you ever find yourself going back to reread those specific notes years later? Or is the act of writing them down just about processing the book in that exact moment?

Mostly the latter. I recently read Middlemarch and it ran over me like a freight train. Trollope on steroids! But it was on a tablet and as much as I wanted to copy or at least highlight all those passages of incredible insight and delicious high-calorie prose, I just had to keep swiping to the next page. If I decide to reread it I'll get a nice used book and mark it all up!

It's interesting, however, to dig out an old book that I may have read decades ago and see all the index cards and underlinings and wonder, "Why exactly did think this was so important?" Other times, however, the profundity shouts loudly out from the past in a very satisfying way.

0 Replies

@Paul260408,

Quote:

The way you described closing your eyes and letting the book drop to the floor is so beautifully poetic—that’s a feeling a tablet can never replicate!

a dropped tablet would make quite the ruckus if it's destination were a hardwood floor... Shocked

i tried an E-reader once, wasn't too thrilled with it.

i have a bookcase full of Stephen King's and enjoy looking at them, an experience a tablet cannot replicate...

0 Replies

@Paul260408,

I've got hundreds of books on shelves and was always happy to read books...as BOOKS.

Got a Kindle a few years back...and I doubt I will ever pick up a book again.

These days, mostly I read while in bed. I built a holder for the Kindle that sets it to the height I want it...and do my reading that way. Mostly I read non-fiction...so that may be the reason for my preference (which does not seem popular with these others).

I doubt I will ever read a book...A BOOK...again. Too easy to do it using the Kindle. Although I suspect I will soon buy a new reader.

Anyone here know which might be the best one?

1 Reply

@Frank Apisa,

Frank Apisa wrote:

I've got hundreds of books on shelves and was always happy to read books...as BOOKS.

Got a Kindle a few years back...and I doubt I will ever pick up a book again.

These days, mostly I read while in bed. I built a holder for the Kindle that sets it to the height I want it...and do my reading that way. Mostly I read non-fiction...so that may be the reason for my preference (which does not seem popular with these others).

I doubt I will ever read a book...A BOOK...again. Too easy to do it using the Kindle. Although I suspect I will soon buy a new reader.

Anyone here know which might be the best one?

Gotta watch whatcha say in these threads. After writing that comment only days ago (actually, I see it was earlier today), my wife asked me to go to our local library for their annual book sale. She didn't buy anything. The books were all over the place.

But I bought two!

So, despite what I said, here are the two books I will be reading soon.

Cleopatra, a life by Stacy Schiff.

Inside Hitler's Bunker by Joachin Fest.

0 Replies

I have just finished David Icke's novel, Extracholesterols from the planet Lardas.

I'm now moving on to his latest novel, Extratesticles from the planet Balzac.

Quite informative.

0 Replies

Physical books vs. E-readers: Has anyone actually made a permanent switch and never looked back?

Related Topics

Quick Links

My Account

able2know