@gollum,
Quote:So, would the nation have the obligation to protect and defend that person (citizen?),
Yes.
Quote:but he would have no obligation to do anything for the nation?
I don't see that reciting words is actually
doing anything for the nation.
Quote:Recently, people in several States suffered damage in a tornado. Does the U.S. Government have a responsibility to help those people?
Absolutely.
Quote:Do those people have any responsibility to the Government?
1. What responsibilities to the government do you want people to have?
2. Would you want everyone to enlist into the military?
3. Would you want everyone to join the profession of first responders?
4. Would you want everyone to join the teaching profession?
5. Would you want everyone to volunteer their time to help out non-profitable charitable organizations?
6. Would you want everyone to volunteer time working in a soup kitchen for the homeless?