@maxdancona,
Quote:Are you really comparing the economic situation of a White middle class family with that of undocumented immigrants? A monthly income of $50,000 is fantastically high for the people you are judging.
No I am saying that the middle class does not typically have a large pot of savings to survive if they go without a paycheck. Many live paycheck to paycheck. What middle class person makes $50k a month? No one I know -
I am discussing immigrants of all kinds and the immigrants I was directly referring and providing examples of are legal immigrants. So it isn't a money thing - that is why I potentially thought it could be cultural.
So why are these immigrants having parties and not isolating (outside of work) or the Greek business owner not using a mask or gloves? He may not be able to socially isolate to keep his business operating, but you would think he would follow the governors guidelines. What does having a party have to do with some sort of luxury they do not have? I honestly doubt they do not have the following or they could not run a business (the Greek pizza guy had no issue running my credit card for example):
- bank accounts,
- the ability to borrow against credit.
- a comfortable salary and your ability to have extra for savings
- your right to claim unemployment if you are unable to work - (maybe this seeing they are business owners)
- your ability to work from home - (yeah because they are running a business)
- and government stimulus money.
Some of these items you listed I do not have myself and many citizens do not have.
As a point - Immigrants are entitled to a stimulus check -
"In order to qualify for the payments, you must be either a U.S. citizen, a lawful permanent resident (green card holder), or a qualifying resident alien. The first two categories are self explanatory. However, who is and is not a qualifying resident alien can get tricky.
The IRS defines a resident alien as someone who either is a green card holder or meets the substantial presence test for the calendar year (January 1 to December 31).
In order to pass the substantial presence test, you must be present in the U.S. for 31 days during the current year, and 183 total days in the past three years. "
Now an undocumented immigrant would not. But you made this about undocumented immigrants - I was discussing all immigrants.
I am not passing judgement - I am simply asking the question to understand. If I was passing judgement I would not ask why? I think it is valid - I think if you care about others you want to know why so you find out how to help.
Why would it be offensive to discuss if something were cultural? It is trying to understand and appreciate where someone is coming from.