Quote:If one person kills another, we might call it evil. Unless that person killed in self defense, or to save another innocent life. The act of killing itself is neither good or evil, it is simply an act. It is the judgement we place on the act which makes it good or evil. And since those judgments are subjective, there is no universal quality of good or evil.
I disagree. No living, conscious, rational being would want to be killed. It is thus universally 'wrong' for a living conscious thing to kill another living conscious thing (at least the ones with rational capacity). The action of killing a person is wrong and can be validated by our reason.
If one were to kill a person and call it 'right', it is irrational since he is also a living, conscious rational being and if he killed another person than he is asserting that living, conscious, rational beings should be killed.
Metaphysically, we don't completely know whether an action can be called right or wrong, but our reason is closest to knowledge and thus it is what I think can tell us what is right and wrong.
You probably disagree, but hey my two cents. :wink: