605
   

NeoPets Riddles (Lenny Conundrums) and Answers Here

 
 
stapel
 
  1  
Reply Wed 31 Oct, 2007 05:47 pm
darkwarrior1234 wrote:
i just gave a full, and correct, explanation for this riddle. simple math really, easy.

Actually, you gave the solution for fitting a half-square with diagonal 50 cm into a box. The half-circle is larger, and would go outside the sides of your box.

To see this, draw your square box with the diagonal. Now draw the half-circle on this diagonal. The half-circle will touch the box (intersect the square) at the ends of the diagonal (two of the corners) and at a third corner. But the half-circle will be outside your square on both sides.

Eliz.
0 Replies
 
nooneatall
 
  1  
Reply Wed 31 Oct, 2007 05:47 pm
the right answer if 2500
goodnight all
0 Replies
 
Blue Dragonfly
 
  1  
Reply Wed 31 Oct, 2007 05:49 pm
nooneatall wrote:
the right answer if 2500
goodnight all


that is what i put too, but it just seems to easy.
0 Replies
 
darkwarrior1234
 
  1  
Reply Wed 31 Oct, 2007 05:51 pm
oh, youre right, eliz.
i guess it would be 2500 i think.
0 Replies
 
cmv
 
  1  
Reply Wed 31 Oct, 2007 05:52 pm
darkwarrior1234 wrote:
oh, youre right, eliz.
i guess it would be 2500 i think.


Yea, I can't think of a way it could be anything else without making a large leap of logic (like cutting the pizza, or folding it, etc, etc). Seems odd that they said to round your answer, but they are probably screwing with us Wink
0 Replies
 
katie8123
 
  1  
Reply Wed 31 Oct, 2007 05:54 pm
i submitted by answer as 2500 too
0 Replies
 
candi5757
 
  1  
Reply Wed 31 Oct, 2007 06:00 pm
Good Luck 2 One & All!

Happy Halloween:)
0 Replies
 
MMK
 
  1  
Reply Wed 31 Oct, 2007 06:04 pm
I sent in 2500 earlier. I already have the avatar so I decided to just go for it Very Happy
0 Replies
 
lem
 
  1  
Reply Wed 31 Oct, 2007 06:05 pm
Let's take a pizza and cut diagonally with respect to original 50x50 box.
We now have half a box free of pizza. So we can shrink it from two sides until it touches the corners. Let's figure out by how much:

The box diagonal is sqrt(2x50^2) = 70.71068
From corner of box to corner of pizza = (70.71068-50)/2 (there are 2 corners) = 10.35534

thats a diagonal of remaining square at each corner. It's side is sqrt(10.35534^2/2) = 7.32233

So we take this much out of each side, now side of a box is 50-7.322233=42.67767

And the area of this box is 42.67767^2 = 1821.383 which rounds to 1821.
0 Replies
 
catsmum
 
  1  
Reply Wed 31 Oct, 2007 06:05 pm
do we include the box lid?
0 Replies
 
darkwarrior1234
 
  1  
Reply Wed 31 Oct, 2007 06:35 pm
no. no lid included.
0 Replies
 
kenshin
 
  1  
Reply Wed 31 Oct, 2007 06:36 pm
I just draw it up to get a feeling of how it's supposed to look like and to get an aprox. value and I got something of "less than 1850" Then I saw lem's post and I was going along the same way with my thinking, but wasn't quite there yet with my math. So thank you for posting. I guess I was not that bad with my aprox. then.
0 Replies
 
lem
 
  1  
Reply Wed 31 Oct, 2007 06:41 pm
kenshin wrote:
I just draw it up to get a feeling of how it's supposed to look like and to get an aprox. value and I got something of "less than 1850" Then I saw lem's post and I was going along the same way with my thinking, but wasn't quite there yet with my math. So thank you for posting. I guess I was not that bad with my aprox. then.


I would encourage someone to check my math tough, because I did it on a scrap of paper in a rush. So even tough I've submitted my answer already, I'd still give no guarantee or anything.

LEM.
0 Replies
 
stapel
 
  1  
Reply Wed 31 Oct, 2007 07:12 pm
lem wrote:
Let's take a pizza and cut diagonally with respect to original 50x50 box....

Another method:

Take the half-circle, drawn with the straight side as a diagonal (rather than horizontal or vertical) line. Draw a square around this, with the squares sides touching the ends of the straight side and two points on the curved portion. Very crudely, the picture looks something like this:

Code:+----------*-------+
| * * |
| 50 * * |
| * *
| * *
|* *
* *|
| * * |
| * * |
+------***---------+

From the midpoint of the diameter (the straight side of the half-circle, labelled "50" above), draw a square by extending a vertical line down to the bottom of the large square and an horizontal line across to the right side of the large square.

Since the sides drawn go from the center to the larger square, where the circle is tangent (and thus perpendicular) to the larger square, this small square is indeed a square (all four corners are ninety degrees), and the sides must (being radii) have length 25.

From the horizontal line in the smaller square, draw a vertical up to the point where the straight side of the half-circle intersects the larger square. This forms a 45-45-90 triangle with hypotenuse 25 (being half of the straight side with length 50). Then the height of the triangle must be 25/sqrt[2].

Adding, we get that the side of the larger square must be 25 + 25/sqrt[2], so the area must be (25 + 25/sqrt[2])^2, or about 1821.3834764....

Assuming that this is the configuration that the "Lenny" authors intended we get an area of 1821, when rounded to the nearest whole number.

Please check my work.

Eliz.
0 Replies
 
Milarepa
 
  1  
Reply Wed 31 Oct, 2007 07:38 pm
lem wrote:
Let's take a pizza and cut diagonally with respect to original 50x50 box.
We now have half a box free of pizza. So we can shrink it from two sides until it touches the corners. Let's figure out by how much:

The box diagonal is sqrt(2x50^2) = 70.71068
From corner of box to corner of pizza = (70.71068-50)/2 (there are 2 corners) = 10.35534

thats a diagonal of remaining square at each corner. It's side is sqrt(10.35534^2/2) = 7.32233

So we take this much out of each side, now side of a box is 50-7.322233=42.67767

And the area of this box is 42.67767^2 = 1821.383 which rounds to 1821.


I worked this through similar reasoning and got the same answer. I hope this is the way the Neopets gurus got their answer...
0 Replies
 
lem
 
  1  
Reply Wed 31 Oct, 2007 07:46 pm
stapel wrote:
lem wrote:
Let's take a pizza and cut diagonally with respect to original 50x50 box....

Another method:

Take the half-circle, drawn with the straight side as a diagonal (rather than horizontal or vertical) line. Draw a square around this, with the squares sides touching the ends of the straight side and two points on the curved portion. Very crudely, the picture looks something like this:

Code:+----------*-------+
| * * |
| 50 * * |
| * *
| * *
|* *
* *|
| * * |
| * * |
+------***---------+

From the midpoint of the diameter (the straight side of the half-circle, labelled "50" above), draw a square by extending a vertical line down to the bottom of the large square and an horizontal line across to the right side of the large square.

Since the sides drawn go from the center to the larger square, where the circle is tangent (and thus perpendicular) to the larger square, this small square is indeed a square (all four corners are ninety degrees), and the sides must (being radii) have length 25.

From the horizontal line in the smaller square, draw a vertical up to the point where the straight side of the half-circle intersects the larger square. This forms a 45-45-90 triangle with hypotenuse 25 (being half of the straight side with length 50). Then the height of the triangle must be 25/sqrt[2].

Adding, we get that the side of the larger square must be 25 + 25/sqrt[2], so the area must be (25 + 25/sqrt[2])^2, or about 1821.3834764....

Assuming that this is the configuration that the "Lenny" authors intended we get an area of 1821, when rounded to the nearest whole number.

Please check my work.

Eliz.


Sounds good to me. You took the same configuration as I did, just calculated the box size using different pieces. Since your answer is the same as mine, it gives me an idea that it may be the one...

Let's see, submitted about 1hr after release... The problem was a bit tricky... but I doubt I'd make for a gold...
0 Replies
 
stormygoddess
 
  1  
Reply Wed 31 Oct, 2007 08:38 pm
I'm agreeing with the latest 2 methods posted. I am a very visual person, so I went and got last night's pizza box and some paper and made a representation half-pizza so I could move it around inside the original box and measure, then subtract from each side any unused area. I came up with about the same area as the two methods above. Therefore I'm submitting that as my answer.

GL to all.
0 Replies
 
edstock
 
  1  
Reply Fri 2 Nov, 2007 06:29 pm
lem and stapel both have good solutions. The one remaining assumption that needs to be addressed is that the best configuration is when the cut edge of the half pizza is turned at 45 degrees to the edges of the square box.

Assume the half pizza is turned so that the cut edge is somewhere between 0 and 90 degrees from the horizontal. (0 degrees means it is at the top with the round part below, while 90 degrees means the cut edge is on the left side with the round part to the right.) In either of these cases, we will require a 50x50 box to match the length of the cut edge (and the original whole pizza will fit in the same box).

For any intermediate position, let A be the left/bottom end of the cut edge, and B the right/top end. Let P be the center point of the cut edge. For any angle, the closest possible positions of the left and top sides of the box will be where they touch A and B respectively. Let a be the distance from P to that left line and b be the distance from P to that top line. Then a^2 + b^2 = 25^2 = 625. (^ indicates exponentiation)

The minimum distance for the bottom and right sides of the box will be 25 cm from P (the points where the semi-circle reaches out the farthest). So the minimum width of the box will be a + 25 and the minimum height will be b + 25.

Since we are required to have a square box, we need the maximum of these two values: max(a+25, b+25). Now a starts at 25 at 0 degrees and decreases to 0 at 90 degrees, while b goes from 25 down to 0. What we want to find is the minimum value of max(a+25, b+25), or equivalently, the minimum value of max(a, b), where a and b are within this range. a^2 + b^2 = 625 describes a circle of radius 25 and the minimum of max(a,b) in the first quadrant of the circle will occur when a=b, at 45 degrees. Hence, the appropriate position of our half pizza is with the cut edge turned 45 degrees and the solutions given do provide a minimal size for the square pizza box.

And yes, I know it is 2 days after the new Lenny came out and I'm just getting around to it, but life is busy. Someday my avatar will come.
0 Replies
 
lem
 
  1  
Reply Sat 3 Nov, 2007 12:13 pm
edstock wrote:
lem and stapel both have good solutions. The one remaining assumption that needs to be addressed is that the best configuration is when the cut edge of the half pizza is turned at 45 degrees to the edges of the square box.

Assume the half pizza is turned so that the cut edge is somewhere between 0 and 90 degrees from the horizontal. (0 degrees means it is at the top with the round part below, while 90 degrees means the cut edge is on the left side with the round part to the right.) In either of these cases, we will require a 50x50 box to match the length of the cut edge (and the original whole pizza will fit in the same box).

For any intermediate position, let A be the left/bottom end of the cut edge, and B the right/top end. Let P be the center point of the cut edge. For any angle, the closest possible positions of the left and top sides of the box will be where they touch A and B respectively. Let a be the distance from P to that left line and b be the distance from P to that top line. Then a^2 + b^2 = 25^2 = 625. (^ indicates exponentiation)

The minimum distance for the bottom and right sides of the box will be 25 cm from P (the points where the semi-circle reaches out the farthest). So the minimum width of the box will be a + 25 and the minimum height will be b + 25.

Since we are required to have a square box, we need the maximum of these two values: max(a+25, b+25). Now a starts at 25 at 0 degrees and decreases to 0 at 90 degrees, while b goes from 25 down to 0. What we want to find is the minimum value of max(a+25, b+25), or equivalently, the minimum value of max(a, b), where a and b are within this range. a^2 + b^2 = 625 describes a circle of radius 25 and the minimum of max(a,b) in the first quadrant of the circle will occur when a=b, at 45 degrees. Hence, the appropriate position of our half pizza is with the cut edge turned 45 degrees and the solutions given do provide a minimal size for the square pizza box.

And yes, I know it is 2 days after the new Lenny came out and I'm just getting around to it, but life is busy. Someday my avatar will come.


Wow, nice proof! Reminds me of my geometry classes back in school, where not only did we have to solve a problem correctly, but to also prove that this is indeed the correct solution (in fact an incorrectly solved problem with a proof would've probably fetched a "B", while a correct solution without a proof was only good for "C", if at all!) Rolling Eyes

Fortunately LC explicitly asks to only submit a number - I knew it was the optimal position from just looking at it and sketching it up on a paper, but never made a point of actually making a mathematical proof!

This is a good exercise though!

LEM.
0 Replies
 
Gigi82
 
  1  
Reply Wed 7 Nov, 2007 01:57 pm
Dear XXXXXX, Congratulations! You have guessed correctly in the Lenny Conundrum game (round 238). You have won 1493 NP! Because you were in the first 250 to guess correctly, you also have been awarded a Rainbow Melt Pizza, and receive a trophy and the Lenny Conundrum avatar! Yours Sincerely, The Neopets Team!
0 Replies
 
 

Related Topics

Lenny Conundrum 464 - Question by jreneearias
Lenny Conundrum #463 - Discussion by barkie
Lenny Conundrum (wed) DECEMBER 8 2010 - Question by Joanneexoxo
answers - Question by qftcu1
Lenny Conundrum 354 - Discussion by hippiegirl101
lenny conundrum 4/16 - Question by punkd4life3
 
Copyright © 2025 MadLab, LLC :: Terms of Service :: Privacy Policy :: Page generated in 0.08 seconds on 05/04/2025 at 11:46:22