plainoldme wrote:I also tell school supers that literature is studied not so much to keep abreast of the dominant culture but to teach students effective self-expression...
I can sympathize with that. However much we may love whatever it is we teach, it's been my experience that telling a student he or she should learn such-and-such because such-and-such is worth learning for its own sake is a surefire way to make the student tune out. It'd be great if the student does eventually come to agree, but it's just not something we can make happen--not directly, anyway. The student has to find out on his or her own.
My field is music, and I try to impress upon the students early on that music doesn't exist in a vacuum, that like everything else it is encoded with human values and is a document of history--so that to learn about music is to learn about ourselves. (Admittedly, I like to use sneaky examples like Orff's
Carmina Burana, which students probably know from TV commercials but probably don't know was also a staple of Nazi rallies.) Not everyone agrees with this view, of course, and I can usually count on there being a student or two who will try to defend the music on principle. So much the better... it means they're engaged in the material.