@Sturgis,
Good post, I appreciate your objectivity.
A decent chunk of the Bible has been historically substantiated through non-biblical scrolls, tablets, and other ancient writings. From a historical point of view, it's safe to say that the Bible is probably about as accurate as any other history book that details the goings on 2,000+ years ago.
The religious part of it, as with any religion, is taken with faith and it's an individual and personal thing.
Modern organized religion is very, VERY different than what the original churches were outlined to be. The "church" is a group of people that meet, worship, and fellowship. The modern church is a business with payroll to meet and bills to pay.
This is just one man's personal opinion, but modern organized religion is a mockery of what God / Jesus established in biblical times.