0
   

among, considering, of

 
 
Reply Wed 8 Mar, 2017 02:23 pm
Are the three sentences below correct? Do they mean the same thing? If not, what's the difference? Please don't change the word order, I need this word order. I'm aware that "Cognac is my favorite of the three drinks" is a better way of writing it. Thanks very much.

Among the three drinks, cognac is my favorite.
Considering the three drinks, cognac is my favorite.
Of the three drinks, cognac is my favorite.
  • Topic Stats
  • Top Replies
  • Link to this Topic
Type: Question • Score: 0 • Views: 536 • Replies: 7
No top replies

 
View best answer, chosen by Doubtful
layman
 
  1  
Reply Wed 8 Mar, 2017 02:39 pm
@Doubtful,
Doubtful wrote:

Are the three sentences below correct? Do they mean the same thing? If not, what's the difference? Please don't change the word order, I need this word order. I'm aware that "Cognac is my favorite of the three drinks" is a better way of writing it. Thanks very much.

Among the three drinks, cognac is my favorite.
Considering the three drinks, cognac is my favorite.
Of the three drinks, cognac is my favorite.


This one doesn't sound right to me: "Among the three drinks, cognac is my favorite."

"From among...." would make sense. But your favorite is not something that is, itself, among the three. Your favorite is not on the table. It is in your head (or your tastebuds). So it is not "among" the three drinks.

Does that make sense?
perennialloner
 
  1  
Reply Wed 8 Mar, 2017 03:33 pm
@layman,
It doesn't make sense to me.

Can't "among" mean "between"? If so, I'm having trouble distinguishing a significant difference in meaning between "of the three drinks" and "between (or among) the three drinks."
layman
 
  1  
Reply Wed 8 Mar, 2017 03:39 pm
@perennialloner,
perennialloner wrote:

It doesn't make sense to me.

Can't "among" mean "between"? If so, I'm having trouble distinguishing a significant difference in meaning between "of the three drinks" and "between (or among) the three drinks."


Hmmm. Well you talk about "between" and then seem to draw a conclusion about "of" from it somehow.

"Cognac is my favorite of the three" would make sense.

Among is like the plural of between. Usually "between" is used to contrast only two things. "Among" is used with more than two.

I think what he's trying to say here is something like: "From among those three, I would choose cognac as my favorite" but he's trying to take too many shortcuts, I think.
izzythepush
  Selected Answer
 
  2  
Reply Wed 8 Mar, 2017 03:52 pm
@Doubtful,
Whether or not something is strictly correct is not the issue, the issue is sounding like a native speaker of English. Only Of the three drinks, cognac is my favourite. sounds like something a native speaker would say.

The other two sound weird.
0 Replies
 
perennialloner
 
  1  
Reply Wed 8 Mar, 2017 04:01 pm
@layman,
I drew that conclusion because I don't see why, if what you're saying is true, "of the three drinks, cognac is my favorite" would be correct. Shouldn't it be "Of these three drinks, I would choose cognac as my favorite?"
layman
 
  1  
Reply Wed 8 Mar, 2017 04:07 pm
@perennialloner,
perennialloner wrote:

I drew that conclusion because I don't see why, if what you're saying is true, "of the three drinks, cognac is my favorite" would be correct. Shouldn't it be "Of these three drinks, I would choose cognac as my favorite?"


Well, you seem to be suggesting that "of" and "among" are exact synonyms with identical meanings. I don't see them that way.
perennialloner
 
  1  
Reply Wed 8 Mar, 2017 04:18 pm
@layman,
I was suggesting that in this situation they can mean the same thing. I think I understand now, though, how among might be wrong/less correct.
0 Replies
 
 

Related Topics

There is a word for that! - Discussion by wandeljw
Best Euphemism for death and dying.... - Discussion by tsarstepan
Let pupils abandon spelling rules, says academic - Discussion by Robert Gentel
Help me!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! - Question by lululucy
phrase/name of male seducer - Question by Zah03
Shameful sexist languge must be banned! - Question by neologist
Three Word Phrase I REALLY Hate to See - Discussion by hawkeye10
Is History an art or a science? - Question by Olivier5
"Rooms" in a cave - Question by shua
 
  1. Forums
  2. » among, considering, of
Copyright © 2024 MadLab, LLC :: Terms of Service :: Privacy Policy :: Page generated in 0.1 seconds on 12/03/2024 at 12:29:25