@georgeob1,
georgeob1 wrote:In many ways I believe it was just that. The UK Supreme Court is a fairly recent addition to British governance and many past PMs had done the same thing as Johnson and under similar circumstances.
Really? Such was done by "many past PMs" "under similar circumstances"?
The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom was formally established on 1 October 2009, following the
Judicial functions of the House of Lords as the court of last resort within the United Kingdom.
All judgments of the Law Lords since 14 November 1996 to 30 July 2009 are available on the Parliament website.
Judgments prior to 1996 can be found in the archives from 1621 onwards.
Experts more knowable in the UK's constitutional law than I am have said that there is no direct precedent in case law - because this power has not been exercised in this way before.
But even if you and Rees-Mogg are correct that the Supreme Court did a ‘constitutional coup’ - the ruling of the 11 judges was unanimously.
Even if it was ‘the most extraordinary overthrowing of the constitution’ -the court’s decision is final, from which there is no appeal.