Reply
Wed 24 Sep, 2003 04:27 pm
25/09/2003 00:08
27 pilots say will refuse to operate in territories
By Amos Harel, Haaretz Correspondent and Haaretz Service
A group of 27 active reserve duty pilots and retired pilots have sent a letter to Air Force Chief, Major General Dan Halutz, declaring that they refuse to participate in operations against Palestinians in the territories.
"We, veteran pilots and active pilots alike, who have served and who continue to serve the state of Israel for many weeks every year, are opposed to carrying out illegal and immoral attack orders, of the type carried out by Israel in the territories," the group wrote. "We, who have been educated to love the state of Israel and to contribute to the Zionist endeavour, refuse to take part in Air Force attacks in civilian population centers."
The group was referring to Israel's policy of targeted killings of palestinian militants in the territories. Dozens of civilians have been killed in these strikes, which began a few months after the intifada erupted in late September 2000.
News that a group of pilots opposed to the targeted killing policy was coalescing, was first published in Haaretz a week ago.
"The pilots refusing to follow orders will have to face the law," IAF chief Dan Halutz told Channel 10 in response to the letter.
"We must keep things in the right proportions, we are talking about only 27 out of thousands of pilots." Halutz said.
"There is no corps and army more humane and moral than us," Halutz said. He added that if the pilots had received an illegal order, they should have informed their commanders of it, instead of sending a letter before receiving such a command.
Halutz said that refusal to serve was an inappropriate form of protest in the general context, and called it "the mother of all dangers to our People."
Defense Minister Shaul Mofaz reacted to the letter, saying the letter was entirely political and had nothing to morality.
Housing and Construction minister Effi Eitam called for the discharge of the pilots and said the letter was a realization of Arafat's vision of the disintegration of Israeli society, Channel 10 reported.
Sources in the IAF reacted to the letter, saying the signatories were all inactive or veteran pilots who were never asked to carry out targeted assassinations in the territories.
Among the signatories is Brigadier General Yiftah Spector (res.), who was a squadron leader during the 1973 Yom Kippur War.
Several of the signatories have spoken out against operations in the territories in the past.
Whoa, this could get interesting...
Last time it didn't. The last time it was reservists who were staging a silent (as silent as this protest can be) protest.
They refused to talk to the media as they were objecting for personal reasons and did not want to grandstand.
They were briefly incarcerated and nothing became of it.
IDF soldiers staging these protests is not entirely new. Thing is, they never manage the momentum to accomplish anything but hurt themselves.
Let's not come to quick conclusions on this one! There might be some hope; maybe this time, there will be more people willing to question the authority when they command strikes that will kill civilians.
Israeli air force grounds 'refuseniks'
Israeli air force grounds 'refuseniks'
By Justin Huggler in Jerusalem
26 September 2003
The Israeli air force grounded 27 reservist pilots yesterday after they refused to take part in future assassinations of Palestinian militants. Israel's political leaders reacted furiously after some of the pilots appeared on television wearing their uniforms.
In a letter to the air force commander, Dan Halutz, the pilots said that they would refuse to take part in further operations inside the occupied territories. In effect, that meant assassinations, the air force's main role in the West Bank and Gaza Strip. The air force uses helicopter rockets and, less frequently, bombs launched from F16s to assassinate militants. Innocent bystanders are frequently killed. Witnesses have described helicopters firing a second time into a crowd of civilians who gathered to help the wounded.
The pilots described the air force's operation in the occupied territories as "illegal and immoral". One said: "We, who have been educated to love the state of Israel ... refuse to take part in air force attacks in civilian population centres." The former Israeli president, Ezer Weizman, accused the pilots of having no "morality", and said the letter was a "disgrace". They should "put their tail between their legs" and get out of the air force, he added.
The pilots have joined the many Israeli army reservists who refuse to serve in the occupied territories on moral principles - the so-called refuseniks. General Halutz said that he would deal with the pilots in the same way that the army dealt with its refuseniks. The army has made an example of a select few, who have been sentenced to long jail terms.
Israeli raids continued in the occupied territories yesterday. Dina Issa, a Palestinian girl aged three, and an Islamic Jihad leader were killed. An Israeli soldier and three militants were also killed.