@msolga,
AFGHANISTAN
HELMAND PROVINCE - THE LONG AND DIFFICULT ROAD AHEAD
from the BBC , july 11 , 2009
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/8145683.stm
headlines from the report :
Quote: Many have warned that a long and difficult road lies ahead in Helmand province and that there will be more casualties this summer and beyond
and a military historian allan mallison states :
Quote: We can't cut and run from this one. We can't afford to lose
i wonder if mr. mallison can tell us WHY the western nations simply stumbled into afghanistan ?
and perhaps he can tell us what effort would be required to turn things around - and bring freedom from war , death , starvation ... to the "ordinary' afghan people ?
it's usually not that difficult to write about history , but how about writing about the future - beyond saying : "We can't cut and run from this one. We can't afford to lose " - that doesn't really tell us anythinhg of value , does it ?
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
and from the report by the BBC :
Quote:New strategy
The hope, expressed by then Defence Secretary John Reid, that British forces might leave without a shot being fired was a forlorn one, and now sounds hopelessly naive as British troops see some of their fiercest fighting in years.
So far, they have fired more than four million bullets, in a campaign which has cost £5.6bn and 184 British lives - 15 of them this month.
Commanders say the recent rise in the death toll among British and several other coalition forces - most notably the US, which provides the bulk of troops in Afghanistan - is largely down to the current offensives against the Taliban.
That new focus has come from the top in Washington, with the election of President Barack Obama, the publication of a new Afghanistan/Pakistan strategy and the appointment of a new Isaf commander.
The strategy of General Stanley McChrystal is first of all a military push against the Taliban to extend security, in the kind of operations now being seen in Helmand.
The new Isaf commander has made it clear "the population is the prize", and the military effort must go hand-in-hand with progress on the civil side.
Gen McChrystal has warned against causing civilian casualties, which have alienated many Afghans.
Western frustrations
Greater security is essential to the rebuilding effort and to give time and space for good governance to emerge.
And good governance - if it does grow - would help security by convincing the Afghan people that foreign troops are supporting an Afghan state that can bring tangible benefits to their lives.
The relative lack of progress on so many fronts, though, over the past years under President Hamid Karzai has been one of the main Western frustrations.
The levels of corruption within the Afghan government, its ineffectual reach in many provinces and the lack of a real justice system, or yet an effective police force, have all made it harder to convince the Afghan people that they are much better off now.
Despite this, only 23% of people in southern Afghanistan are said to support the Taliban, while support for the Isaf coalition has remained reasonably high despite the campaign's problems.
There is now a gritty realism dawning in the campaign, and the public acknowledgement of just how difficult all this will be in the world's fourth-poorest country, which has been torn and scarred by war for the past three decades.
Many of the Afghan middle classes who might form the backbone of the new Afghanistan have long since fled abroad, though some remain. ( HOW MANY REMAIN ? i wonder - quite a few have now settled in canada . hbg )
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
article from the TORONTO STAR :
many 1,000's of afghans have settled in toronto over the years .
they WERE part of the "backbone" of the afghan society - but theses families have now settled in toronto - and are part of the "backbone" of toronto and canada !
http://www.thestar.com/News/GTA/article/598729
Quote: Baker, realtor, musician, lawyer, counsellor, soccer player, writer " in any conversation with Afghans in Greater Toronto, they will say, "The first thing you have to remember is we are a resilient people."
Such a conversation will invariably be accompanied by a glass of tea.
Afghans are also hospitable people.
After a generation of steady, sorrowful immigration to Canada, as one war bled into another in their homeland, the Afghan community in Toronto is coming of age, producing a homegrown band of young professionals.