A toss-up between posting this here or to the
Wikileaks thread ... under the category of government secrecy/untruths/propaganda/ & lack of transparency.
Just for a minute consider the Afghanistan war/invasion from the perspective of a country which is an ally of the US......
This is an article from
the AGE (a respected Australian newspaper) from earlier this month, about an incident involving a Taliban attack in Tarin Kowt on July 28 last year.
Our (Australian) government, via the Australian Defence Force, had painted this incident in a glowing light, suggesting that the Afghan forces (we've been training to take-over on Australia's withdrawal on 2014) had responded very well to the Taliban attack.
Yet a detailed & initially secret (then heavily censored before release) US army report paints an entirely different picture of the same event, suggesting that the Afghan forces choose not to become involved. ... leading to a chaotic situation, including the death of an Afghan journalist ....
Imagine for a moment that you live in a country (in this case, Australia) whose troops are involved in Afghanistan. How much confidence would you have about the 2014 withdrawal ...or that you were being told the truth about the what is actually occurring in Afghanistan ... or about the wisdom of being involved in this conflict in the first place?
Quote:
Our Afghan partners go missing in action
Tom Hyland
January 15, 2012/Sunday AGE
Whether militia, army or police, the Afghan forces "did not appear to be actively responding to the situation in an organised manner".
A SECRET US Army report has undermined a glowing Australian account of the role Afghan forces played in repelling an unprecedented Taliban attack near Australia's main base in Afghanistan.
The 166-page report obtained by The Sunday Age, raises fresh doubts about the capacity of Afghan forces to take over when Australian and other foreign troops pull out.
The federal government insists the Afghans are on track to take charge of security by 2014, so Australians can leave.
The Australian Defence Force praised what it said was the prompt, professional and co-ordinated Afghan response to the Taliban attack in Tarin Kowt on July 28 last year.
But the US report paints a picture of confusion, with Afghan forces failing to respond to a key part of the Taliban assault - an attempt to kill a militia leader who is a close ally of Australian special forces.
Afghan forces were either absent or stood by and watched as US troops attacked Taliban fighters who had blasted their way into the government broadcasting station adjoining the compound of militia leader Matiullah Khan.
Adding to the confusion was the fact US troops could not distinguish between official Afghan forces and the militia. While Afghan forces repelled a related Taliban assault on the nearby governor's office, US troops were on their own at the broadcasting station.
Standard procedure was for Afghan forces to take the lead in clearing a building where the Taliban were holed up.
In their absence, US troops stormed the building, with disastrous consequences. Two Taliban fighters detonated suicide vests, burying seven soldiers, including the battalion commander, Lieutenant-Colonel David Oeschger, who was seriously wounded.
In what the report says was the ''stress and urgency of the moment'', a US soldier then shot dead Afghan journalist Ahmad Omaid Khpalwak, in the mistaken belief he was a suicide bomber. Afghan forces only moved into the building once the Taliban and the journalist were killed, and wounded Americans were dug out of the rubble.
The US report also suggests the Australian response to the attacks was more extensive than the ADF revealed at the time.
Initially classified as secret, the report was heavily censored before being released to The Sunday Age under the
US Freedom of Information Act. Even so, it contains detail rarely, if ever, released by Australian agencies ....<cont>
http://www.theage.com.au/world/our-afghan-partners-go-missing-in-action-20120114-1q0j2.html
-