Ban this Book

For example, Danny-boy, a number of the folk on this board are ethnic Jews. Some of whom do not support Israel at all, some who are selectively supportive of Israel and some who normally support Israel.

Perhaps a little thinking and research would be helpful.

Kiwimac

kiwimac wrote:

For example, Danny-boy, a number of the folk on this board are ethnic Jews. Some of whom do not support Israel at all, some who are selectively supportive of Israel and some who normally support Israel.

Perhaps a little thinking and research would be helpful.

Kiwimac

But then, by D-b's logic, aren't those Jews who do not support Israel at all, or who are selectively supportive of Israel, and those some who normally support Israel, but not one-hundred percent unquestioningly, self-hating Jews?

kiwimac wrote:

Simply because you do not like the book is no reason to ban it. Oh and for the record, anti-israel DOES NOT EQUAL anti-semitic.

Kiwimac

yes they should be banned
and yes being anti Israeli is anti semitic no one should be allowed to question Israel.

Well,

You could SAY that, I s'pose but t'would be best not to be TOO close when you did! Legitimate criticism of a government's action does not mean any kind of hatred. Not everything a government does stands up to day's light.

Kiwimac

kiwimac wrote:

Well,

You could SAY that, I s'pose but t'would be best not to be TOO close when you did! Legitimate criticism of a government's action does not mean any kind of hatred. Not everything a government does stands up to day's light.

Kiwimac

I am in total agreement, Kiwimac.

no one should be allowed to question Israel since that is the refuge of anti-semitism.
Anyway why dont people talk about china or Russia?? instead.

ummm, no, some books just deserve not to be read