Osso, I was reacting to Yitwail's question to DD.
yitwail wrote:nimh, you're assuming that there were an average of 1500 jumpers and 40,000 jumps every year since 1981, which i doubt. also, i wasn't comparing it to suicide...i was just getting DD's views on what government should or should not do to protect people from self-destructive behavior.
Yeah, but there's self-destructive behavior and self-destructive behavior. It comes in all shades. Smoking is self-destructive behavior too.
In that context, the comparison you made in response to DD's "fail[ing] to see why the government is required to protect people from their own risky behavior" - ie, yeah, so what about suicide attempts? - was indeed a bit "extreme", re the numbers we appear to be roughly talking about here. Extreme enough, IMHO, to be irrelevant. You might better ask, should the government try to prevent people from - I dunno - climbing the Mt. Everest for example ... even there proportional casualty numbers are far higher.