Get someone to do sthg & get someone doing sthg

Forums: Esl
Email this Topic • Print this Page

Is there any difference in meaning between "to get someone to do something" and "to get someone doing something"?

If so, when should I use each of them?

Would you please give me a few examples?

Thank you

Topic Stats
Top Replies
Link to this Topic

Type: Question • Score: 0 • Views: 519 • Replies: 7

No top replies

@paok1970,

paok1970 wrote:

Is there any difference in meaning between "to get someone to do something" and "to get someone doing something"?

If so, when should I use each of them?

Would you please give me a few examples?

Thank you

Without any context, it's hard to even understand your question. Is a particular problem or task meant by "something," or is the sense that nobody is doing anything about anything--a bunch of lazy bums?

1 Reply

@layman,

Should I say, "I got him to clean his bedroom" or "I got him cleaning his bedroom"?

If both are possible, do they mean the same thing?

Thank you

1 Reply

@paok1970,

paok1970 wrote:

Should I say, "I got him to clean his bedroom" or "I got him cleaning his bedroom"?

If both are possible, do they mean the same thing?

Thank you

Not quite the same. The first one suggests that the task has already been accomplished. The second one suggests that it is a task still in progress.

1 Reply

@paok1970,

paok1970 wrote:

Is there any difference in meaning between "to get someone to do something" and "to get someone doing something"?

If so, when should I use each of them?

Would you please give me a few examples?

Thank you

I think you already asked this.

To get someone to do something means to get someone to start and complete a task. I got my son to clean his bedroom. I got my assistant to file all the reports.

To get someone doing something means to get someone to start something, or to take up a habit or practice. I got my sister preparing the meal then went in the garden. I got my mother reading the Bible every day.

0 Replies

@layman,

And if I say, "I had him clean his bedroom," does it have the same meaning as "I got him to clean his bedroom"?

Again, thank you very much for the help.

1 Reply

@paok1970,

paok1970 wrote:

And if I say, "I had him clean his bedroom," does it have the same meaning as "I got him to clean his bedroom"?

That 'had' usage is mainly American. 'Had someone do something' means 'ordered someone to do something' e.g. a servant, employee, or contractor, whereas 'got someone to do something' can mean 'persuaded someone to do something'.

1 Reply

@centrox,

Quote:

That 'had' usage is mainly American. 'Had someone do something' means 'ordered someone to do something' e.g. a servant, employee, or contractor, whereas 'got someone to do something' can mean 'persuaded someone to do something'.

They are as Centrox has described but the meaning can also be neutral, without any hint of "ordered" or "persuaded", ie. it can be a cooperative venture.

I had Camille do the dishes and I got John to mow the lawn. Bill was on making beds, Joan the laundry and me the vacuuming.

0 Replies

Get someone to do sthg & get someone doing sthg

Related Topics

Quick Links

My Account

able2know