@farmerman,
Quote:Its a curse that the progs must visibly bear.
We have broad shoulders. Just born that way.
Quote:self-deprication, irony, and abstract composition are not things of which we usually accuse Conservatives .
Im always amazed at how literal the conservatives are, even when they are trying damned hard to be non- linear in their thought.
This gets really close, I think. We've touched briefly on the self-deprecation thing in a lot of the humor we tend to love. I think a very important/relevant aspect here is that this sort of humor counts oneself as quite like all others - the acceptance that we're all a bit stupid or frivolous or silly or hung-up or nervous or imperfect, etc. Inherent in all this is a notion of the community of humans and inclusiveness, "Yes, me too." Where a personality is more comfortable with an "us/them" binary framing, that sort of humor doesn't work.
Something similar seems to be happening with conservatives' zest for conceptions of (and behavioral adherence to) the sacred versus the profane binary opposition. Other than in magnitude, there's not much if any difference between the perpetrators of the Hebdo murders and those who protested the Curb Your Enthusiasm episode where a drop of Larry David's urine splashed onto an illustration of Jesus just below one eye, the christian owners of which took to be a tear drop and a miracle!
Humor quite consistently pushes at the boundaries not just of traditional modes of thought (or cliches) but also of what is acceptable to think and to say in public. George Carlin is a rather apt example. When SJ Perlman said that "the office of humor is to offend", I think this is what he was talking about.