A great review..I wish I'd written
"No Beach Boys LP aside from All Summer Long has such a large gap between its best and worst songs. Even non-fans have to appreciate the production of "California Girls" and "Help Me, Rhonda"; the rest of us can just sit and enjoy perfection on record. Then there's the filler, from the half-assed cover of "Girl From New York City" to "I'm Bugged at My Old Man," which only Brian Wilson could have written, let alone put on an album.
For me, Summer Days starts on track 3. I don't know many people who would be able to sit through the opening duo of "The Girl From New York City" and "Amusement Parks U.S.A.," one of the most grating songs in the Beach Boys' catalog. Why Capitol wanted Brian Wilson to keep pumping out more tripe like this I will never know. From then on, it's pretty smooth sailing. "Then I Kissed Her" is up there with the best Beach Boys covers of Spector songs; you can tell it's a cover, but Wilson has made the song his own. "Salt Lake City" is bearable, but I usually skip to "Girl Don't Tell Me," Carl Wilson's first lead vocal and one of the best obscure Beach Boys songs.
"Let Him Run Wild" and "You're So Good to Me" are letdowns, of course, but that's only because of the two tracks they follow. "Summer Means New Love" is a nice break, especially leading into the crazy "Bugged at My Old Man." If you like Love You, you will like this track; if not, you won't. Anyone who knows the story of the Wilsons' relationship with their father will recognize that the lyrics are not entirely whimsical. The album finishes up with some classic Beach Boys a cappella beauty.
One of the great parts about listening to Summer Days is that a little bit of almost every future Beach Boys album is on here. You can hear the precursors of songs from great LPs like Pet Sounds and Wild Honey as well as awful ones like 15 Big Ones and Beach Boys 1985; not always a good thing for the average person, but awesome for the fan."