@Crazyman582,
Crazyman582 wrote:Glossy but not really silvery. What of the scratches?
I can't explain the scratches, other than maybe it was scratched with something copper colored, or maybe it was an artifact of reflection on the scratch.
Here are some photo's of tumbled Hematite. The image you provided just looked like this to me, but the image was kind of fuzzy so you will have to judge for yourself.