Re: Why is water essential to life?
Exception wrote:A question that's been bugging me for some time is, why do biologists seem to assume that water is a prerequisite for life?
Because the only type of life they have ever seen, evolved in water.
Eos has listed a number of unique characteristics of water, which may seem to be a prerequisite of life, but that does assume that life is limited to the type we are familiar with.
Other compounds have very unique characteristics at different pressures and temperatures. Robert L. Forward described life on a Neutron Star in his novel _Dragon's Egg_, and David Brin speculated on the possibilities of life in the fluid plasmas of our sun (and other stars) in his novel _Sundiver_, and Gregory Benford wrote of magnetic and mechanical life in various forms. All three men are physists who put a bit more than just random speculation into their models, even though they are fictional.
Until we have another type of "life" to compare to, it's reasonable to assume that our foundation is the most likely foundation, but we must always remind ourselves that we are working from a single data point, so we really don't know if we are "normal" or not in the grand scheme of things. This is one reason we search with such desperation to find even the merest scrap of life from somewhere else, for even two data points alone, are vastly more revealing than one.
Good question. Thanks.