@Phoenix32890,
I also loved Chris Noth on the old L&O, but much less so on Criminal Intent--although I'm enjoying him now on The Good Wife.
I found D'Onofrio's twitchiness and mannerisms very annoying after a while, but Erbe was perfect, and a good compliment to D'Onofrio.
And, I agree with you about Goldblum, he was great.