3

# Does anyone understand this?

Tue 27 Dec, 2011 08:48 am
Which composer wrote 10 symphonies, the numbers of three of them, all in a minor key, adding up to one?
• Topic Stats
• Top Replies
Type: Question • Score: 3 • Views: 1,736 • Replies: 4
No top replies

fresco

1
Tue 27 Dec, 2011 10:29 am
@sophocles,
Mahler wrote 10 symphonies. The numbers part escapes me.
Setanta

1
Tue 27 Dec, 2011 11:55 am
There were four symphonies (alleged) which were never published or performed in Mahler's lifetime, and that is perhaps an allusion to one or more of them. However, even among the symphonies published and performed in his life time, there were more than three in a minor key.
0 Replies

coluber2001

1
Tue 27 Dec, 2011 12:34 pm
@fresco,
Mahler wrote 8 symphonies, then Das Lied Von Der Erde, which is subtitled a symphony, then the 9th symphony, then a partial 10th symphony.
0 Replies

Shapeless

2
Wed 28 Dec, 2011 09:37 am
This sounds like a reference to Bruckner. In addition to his nine officially numbered symphonies, he wrote a symphony in F Minor known officially as the "Study Symphony" (without a number) as well as a symphony in D Minor known officially as "Symphony No. 0." If you add those to his Symphony No. 1 in C Minor, then you get a sum of 1.

A slight catch is that several of his other numbered symphonies are also in the minor key. Then again, the question doesn't say we have to add all of the minor key symphonies, just three of them.

A bigger catch is that Bruckner wrote more than ten symphonies, depending on how you count them. If you count only the officially numbered symphonies plus the Symphony No. 0, then you get ten; but excluding the Study Symphony messes up the "sum of 1" solution. If we do count the Study Symphony, then he has (at least) eleven. (I say "at least" because some historians argue that many of the other symphonies exist in several versions, some of them different enough from the "final" versions as to constitute a different piece entirely, sort of the same way Beethoven's various attempts at a Fidelio overture are now considered four different pieces.)
0 Replies