@gungasnake,
gungasnake wrote:
This one is almost a bit of a mystery to me but the author sees it as Muhammed (MHBH) having blessed cousin marriages early on combined with the general injunction against marrying outside of the religion.
Normally I'd assume that Pakistanis and Indian muslims would be descendants of Tamerlane's organization and the Moghuls but that implies at least some connection with real Mongols and real Mongols and other high Asians always understood the problem with inbreeding and forbade it. Mongols as I read it can't even marry inside their own TRIBE, much less their own family.
Other than that the fact that the thing is so widespread in the muslim world pretty much says it's mostly the religion and has little to do with local customs, over that big an area.
I am not agreeing with the premise so much as the conclusion, since I believe there is some compacting of the gene pool among Arabs for the above stated reason... Powerful people always consider poligamy to be a good thing, since they can afford it; but tribal people, and all of humanity are very concentrated, with few actual differences... Incest is the greatest taboo among tribal people because they were so prone to the illnesses of gene concentration... Given a chance, people intermarry, and if myths are any guide they still seek near and familiar people to mate with... I actually own a good book on the subject called Kinship and Marriage in early Arabia, by W. Robertson Smith... But Lowell Thomas's book: With Lawrance in Arabia talks about the importance of wealth to marriage among the Bedoins... Without wishing to demean the Prophet, Peace be upon him, I think it may be possible that he expressed God's blessing on poligamy out of his own desires rather than common sense... Of course, in a warrior society, and the world has known many, it is just as likely that girls will suffer infanticide, and since I believe that the Holy Koran forbids this, there was no alternative but for men to marry the widows of the falllen...The level of violent expansion that followed the death of the Prophet is long past, and they should of their own accord, change their behavior...