Curiosity? Who actually likes Harry Potter?

Forums: Books, Harry Potter, Literature, Writing, Book
Email this Topic • Print this Page

I know religious conservatives don’t like it because of the witchcraft, and those of the occult don’t like it because of its ludicrous portrayal of witchcraft. So who likes it? Non-religious types? I’m just curious.

Topic Stats
Top Replies
Link to this Topic

Type: Discussion • Score: 12 • Views: 2,889 • Replies: 17

[+5] - George - 12/03/2010Many religious folk (including Wiccans) are clear on the "fiction" concept. Some, alas, are not.

me, thats who

0 Replies

@MrIVI,

Judging from his appearances on television, it would have to be some other guys...

0 Replies

@MrIVI,

MrIVI wrote:

I know religious conservatives don’t like it because of the witchcraft, and those of the occult don’t like it because of its ludicrous portrayal of witchcraft. So who likes it? Non-religious types? I’m just curious.

They don't mind magic... They don't like black magic..

0 Replies

@MrIVI,

Why do you think religious types don't like it?

I happen to love it and not be religious BUT I know many many people who are religious who love it too and just percentages-wise it couldn't be as wildly popular as it is without a large religious following.

0 Replies

I like it very much, and, while I don't profess to me a member of any Faith, I believe in God and don't have a whole lot of problem with people who are religious -- including Wiccans.

0 Replies

Many religious folk (including Wiccans) are clear on the "fiction" concept.
Some, alas, are not.

0 Replies

@MrIVI,

I think the majority of Americans are not conservatively religious, wiccan or non-religious. I mean, most Americans are mildly to moderately (non-wiccan) religious.

0 Replies

I thought they were good reads. I think there are a very few people who don't care for them for religious reasons, but that doesn't mean that religious people don't like them.

0 Replies

@MrIVI,

I really enjoyed the first couple, but got really annoyed in the middle that Harry is too cocky and really not very bright.

Thought the last book came out of left field and could really have used some editing.

I'm a non-churchgoing person, but I, too, am aware of many church goers who enjoyed the series.

I think the folks wailing about witchcraft are more in the line of attention whores than anything else.

0 Replies

harry potter sucks!!!!!!!!

1 Reply

@rapper4life,

really, oh man, now i'm gonna have to re-evaluate my whole life

1 Reply

@djjd62,

I told you not to waste your money of that flying broom.

1 Reply

@Green Witch,

yeah, stupid thing barely hovered, still, it was handy for getting the cobwebs off the ceiling

0 Replies

I liked the books quite a bit. I actually began re-reading them a few days ago because I realized I had not read them for several years. I am very religious, though neither Christian or Wiccan. I have heard of a lot of religious groups speaking out against the books based on the use of witch craft and think it quite ludicrous.

0 Replies

I read the first four books and thought they were good. I recall wishing they had been available when I was a kid. But I did not have the unflagging interest to complete the task. If I were a kid, I would have done so, I think.

0 Replies

@MrIVI,

I haven't read the books, but have watched all the movies several times over. Needless to say, I love them.

It has nothing to do with my non-religiousness, for sure. I've always had an affinity for fiction based on magic, ghosts, etc. Maybe I'll be loathed in certain non-believer circles for such paradoxical inclinations, but I can't help it really.

The child in me just loves that stuff.

0 Replies

@MrIVI,

Who doesn't? I think the book is so popular because its about a boy who is still scared but does the right thing anyway.

0 Replies

Curiosity? Who actually likes Harry Potter?

Related Topics

Quick Links

My Account

able2know