@parados,
Quote:"It isn't good editing" is the main statement. It means the piece is not an example of good editing.
"if it can even be considered editing" in no way affects the meaning of the first phrase. It means there is a question as to whether it is editing not as to whether it is good editing or not.
1) "
It isn't good editing" is the main statement. It means
the piece is not an example of good editing.
In your first sentence, marked 1), the underlined 'it', marked in bold, means 'the piece'.
2) "if
it can even be considered editing"
In your second sentence, marked 2), 'it', in italics, also refers to 'the piece'. Since there is only one piece that is being referred to and both of the pronouns, 'it', refer to that one piece, for you to suggest that the 'if' clause "in no way affects the meaning of the first phrase", is fatuous on its face.
The piece isn't good editing, if the piece can even be considered editing.
Quote:
So.. it isn't an example of good editing. There is even a question as to whether it could be classified as editing at all. But whether it is editing or not, it would still not be an example of good editing.
The horse is dead, Parados. Why do you continue flogging it? As I said, that's just not like you.