Takshshila wrote:Hello and Regards to u all Stalwarts out there!!!!
I bought the book after reading this thread and I have finished it in two days....
Now I m not Christian yet Convent Schooling gives me brief background so I beg of u all to tell me how far is the speculation justified....Lets not go for whether Brown is rite or rong. The theory has strong hold or not thats all.......
Waiting............
Any speculation is justified. Brown's tongue-in-cheek speculation is certainly not totally made up out of whole cloth. The historical people and places he mentions are all real historical figures, not imaginary. But we might as well ask, how much of the Bible is true, how much the imagination of later writers. The Gospels were all written well after the fact.
My point in starting this thread, of course, was that the truth or falsity of Brown's statements is completely ireelevant to enjoyment of the book. It is a tour-de-force of fast moving scenes, absurd situations, and a general hilarity which is easy to miss if you take it as a serious work. As I said earlier, I don't for a moment think that Brown himself believes half of these speculations (none of which, btw, is original with him).
If you're reading
DeVinci to gain some theological, philosophical or historical insights, you're reading the wrong book.