@xris,
William and Catchy,
I found some of the music in this thread incredibly beautiful. I adore Adiemus; William, I think you've made good observations about Jenkins's compelling technique. I was drawn to the magical Namarie song and its language -- I went to Youtube to read more about it. There is an element of ineffable enchantment here.
Xris,
I'd very much appreciate it if you could post or suggest an example of music that resonates with you -- I understand, of course, that it might/not resonate with me, but I would like to hear it.
I'm curious, do you generally dislike orchestrated and "studio sound" music, or only when that sound becomes too formulaic, or is applied to another genres which you feel are inappropriate for it, like traditional music?
I do agree with you that some the modern "celtic" sound has taken a left turn, though I did not hear it in the LOTR music posted in thiis thread. And while I like quite a bit of Adiemus, I, like you, hear too much "studio sound" in much of Enya's music.
In light of your comment about an old man honestly commenting on his life, I'd like your (and, of course, others') opinion on the following Youtube post. WARNING: BLUEGRASS. But this short semi-documentary music video has an interesting history -- well, interesting to me, since I live in bluegrass country.
Kenny Baker, probably nearing 70 when the vid was made, was the late Bill Monroe's fiddle player for years -- and though Bill Monroe is credited with writing the exquisite bluegrass fiddle tune "Jerusalem Ridge", everyone "knows" Kenny Baker deserves the credit.
So this local documentary musical vid was made in 1985, showing Kenny and Bill and a few of the old boys sitting around the porch (the location looked a bit like our local Long Hollow Jamboree, which has weekly bluegrass jam sessions, but there were chickens clucking in the background, so I'm not sure...)
Kenny picked up the fiddle, the boys start jamming -- and still, at his advanced age, Kenny played every note of Jerusalem Ridge to sweet perfection. He remains (IMO) the only fiddle player who has ever "gotten it right". I've listened to well over two dozen other fiddlers play that tune, but no one else even comes close to Kenny Baker's sound; it's like a different song in his hands. It's HIS tune.
I really do love this simple bluegrass front-porch video -- it seems, to me, to be "honest". What do others think? Am I getting close, Xris, or am I way off base?
I note that this vid won't embed so you have to click on the underlined "watch on youtube" in the middle of the screen which appears after you click the big arrow.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bpzoLAwZ-gs
rebecca